SPL Predictions: Rangers disappointed again while Kilmarnock are ready to rise
by CaughtOffside Team on August 17th, 2007
Craig delivers the final part in his 3 part series on the Scottish Premier League, with predictions for Rangers, Kilmarnock and more.
Kilmarnock
Finished 5th in the last 2 seasons, and will be hoping to do the same again with what is basically the same squad of players. Have spent the summer fending off advances from Rangers for star striker Steven Naismith. Rangers’ first offer was an insulting £400k over 2 years, and while this has been increased to £1.5m over 2 years, Killie want £2m for the Scotland international. Naismith handed in a transfer request before withdrawing it a week later and now looks set to stay at Rugby Park. Only signing has been 20 year-old midfielder Craig Bryson from Clyde who will add depth to that area of the park. Defender Gordon Greer left for Doncaster and midfielder Peter Leven joined Chesterfield, but youngster Ryan O’Leary will fill Greer’s boots, while Leven was never a regular anyway. Reserve goalkeeper Graeme Smith joined Rangers for free, and is now 3rd choice goalie at Ibrox. Naismith’s partnership with Colin Nish was the most prolific in the league last season, with 28 goals between them (Naismith 15, Nish 13) and a lot will depend on those two again. Manager Jim Jefferies likes his side to play the ball on the deck and Killie usually set out to attack teams. Defence is notoriously leaky but if they can plug the gaps they could challenge for Europe.
Key Player – Steven Naismith
One to watch – Ryan O’Leary
Prediction – 4th
Motherwell
Struggled towards the end of last season, and manager Maurice Malpas was shown the exit door to be replaced by Mark McGhee. McGhee has appeared slightly arrogant in his interviews since taking over, and may underestimate the quality of the league. His side will struggle after losing top scorer Scott McDonald to Celtic and midfielder Brian Kerr to Hibs. Replaced Kerr with combative midfielder Simon Mensing from St Johnstone which looks like a good piece of business. McDonald will be harder to replace, but Chris Porter has joined from Oldham for that purpose. Squad looks rather weak on paper and although they have won their first 2 games of the season they could struggle. Goals will be hard to come by and Porter will have to settle in quickly. Will probably be involved in a three-way battle with Gretna and St Mirren at the bottom of the table and may be the ones who lose out.
Key Player – Stephen Craigan
One to watch – Mark Reynolds
Prediction – 12th
Rangers
Have been impressive since Walter Smith abandoned his country to rejoin the club – but will have a difficult job stopping Celtic from making it 3 titles in a row. Spent the early part of the summer searching in the free transfer market, snapping up Alan Gow from Falkirk, Kirk Broadfoot from St Mirren, Jean-Claude Darcheville from Bordeaux, Graeme Smith from Kilmarnock Reserves and Roy Carroll from West Ham. But after these underwhelming signings, they have started to flash the cash, first signing winger DaMarcus Beasley from PSV for £700k, then taking Lee McCulloch from Wigan for £2.25m. Defender Carlos Cuellar joined for around £2.5m from Osasuna and right-back Steven Whittaker cost £2m from Hibs. Gabon striker Daniel Cousin joined from Lens for £1.5m, which looks like a lot of money for a 30 year-old. Two more of Paul le Guen’s dud signings left the club, with Karl Svensson joining Caen and Libor Sionko moving to FC Copenhagen, which leaves only Sasa Papac and Filip Sebo remaining at Ibrox. Walter Smith can be a little cautious in the league, especially away from home when he often plays 4-5-1. Can tend to be over-reliant on the goals of Kris Boyd, who is criticised by supporters despite being top scorer in the SPL 2 years in a row. Rangers are certainly much stronger than last year and have good strength in depth, but while they will run Celtic closer, they may just lack the little bit of quality which would make them champions.
Key Player – Kris Boyd
One to watch – Steven Lennon
Prediction – 2nd
St Mirren
Struggled badly towards the end of last year and only stayed up last year on the back of early season form. However they secured a major coup in signing Craig Dargo from Inverness and his goals will be key to securing safety again, especially with the departure of top scorer John Sutton to Wycombe. Defender Will Haining’s acquisition from Oldham was popular with the fans – he’s married to glamour model Michelle Marsh. Ex-Arsenal keeper Mark Howard joined from Cardiff and midfielder Gary Mason was signed from relegated Dunfermline. Argentinian full-back Franco Miranda also joined from Swedish side Helsingborgs after a successful trial. Defender Kirk Broadfoot joined Rangers and he may prove difficult to replace. Boss Gus McPherson has often been criticised for being too defensive but his side are usually hard to beat, and if Dargo stays fit then his goals should keep them up.
Key Player – Craig Dargo
One to watch – Chris Smith
Prediction – 10th


Scottie D - August 17th, 2007 at 1:35 pm
You have Motherwell to finish last? Kilmarnock to finish 4th above Aberdeen and Hibs down at 6th.
Have to say i strongly disagree with those choices, i think Aberdeen will continue on after a strong 3rd finish last season and Motherwell will shine under new management, a positive start from them already this season.
One to watch - Steven Lennon? What… watch him sit on the bench as a spectator, if Watty is planning using Whittaker in midfield, out of Thomson, Hemdani or Ferguson going to drop for his position.
As for league winners, very little in it - i think whoever has the most sucess in Europe could be a factor on the domestic scene, shame we have to wait till October for the first old firm game, but we’ll have a good standing on the league by then, i think it will differ from your views.
Betis - August 17th, 2007 at 1:57 pm
I think Killie and Aberdeen will fight it out for 4th, it’ll be a lot closer than people think and just as much in it as the race for the title.
I also think Kris Boyd is overrated, we’ll see him slump this season
Anonymous - August 17th, 2007 at 3:23 pm
[quote comment=”55546″]I think Killie and Aberdeen will fight it out for 4th, it’ll be a lot closer than people think and just as much in it as the race for the title.
I also think Kris Boyd is overrated, we’ll see him slump this season[/quote]
Slump to what? Top scorer by just a couple of goals? He’s been top scorer for the past 2 seasons. I think even the most cynical of supporters would have to concede he’s the best goal scorer in the league. I’d like to know who you think will be top this season?
Scotty D - very sensible comments mate. Perhaps you would have been better writing the original article - agree with everything you say!
craig - August 17th, 2007 at 5:13 pm
[quote comment=”55543″]You have Motherwell to finish last? Kilmarnock to finish 4th above Aberdeen and Hibs down at 6th.
Have to say i strongly disagree with those choices, i think Aberdeen will continue on after a strong 3rd finish last season and Motherwell will shine under new management, a positive start from them already this season.
One to watch - Steven Lennon? What… watch him sit on the bench as a spectator, if Watty is planning using Whittaker in midfield, out of Thomson, Hemdani or Ferguson going to drop for his position.
As for league winners, very little in it - i think whoever has the most sucess in Europe could be a factor on the domestic scene, shame we have to wait till October for the first old firm game, but we’ll have a good standing on the league by then, i think it will differ from your views.[/quote]
Which young Rangers player would you rather I picked - they don’t really have any.
Hibs finished 6th last year with a better squad so I hardly think that’s an unlikely prediction.
Anonymous - August 17th, 2007 at 7:10 pm
Sorry - what is SPL? Is this a joke?… predictions Celtic win league, again. This league is a bore, who cares.
Scottie D - August 17th, 2007 at 11:04 pm
[quote comment=”55603″]Sorry - what is SPL? Is this a joke?… predictions Celtic win league, again. This league is a bore, who cares.[/quote]
Thanks for your contribution, if you don’t like it - then why bother to take the time and post here? Perhaps if your local team were Scottish then you might have something interesting to say, but say what you will, theres passion on all levels thru out the SPL fans and teams.
And Craig, you emphasize on young Rangers players, whilst i agree we all need players for the future, the current reserves who just won the reserve league and cup, beating Celtic 5-0 in the final, are not quite ready for first team action.
My opinion in one to watch for Rangers - Carlos Cuellar, he looked solid in the pre-season games against Ajax and Chelsea, and the fact of the matter is Gers haven’t conceded in 5 games this season so far due to his work rate with Weir.
I know my post is biast against my team, but thats a fans view, perhaps in future in might be better tan what you have stated, being an Arsenal fan as your post says.
Cheers mate.
Scottie.
craig - August 17th, 2007 at 11:19 pm
[quote comment=”55622″][quote comment=”55603″]Sorry - what is SPL? Is this a joke?… predictions Celtic win league, again. This league is a bore, who cares.[/quote]
Thanks for your contribution, if you don’t like it - then why bother to take the time and post here? Perhaps if your local team were Scottish then you might have something interesting to say, but say what you will, theres passion on all levels thru out the SPL fans and teams.
And Craig, you emphasize on young Rangers players, whilst i agree we all need players for the future, the current reserves who just won the reserve league and cup, beating Celtic 5-0 in the final, are not quite ready for first team action.
My opinion in one to watch for Rangers - Carlos Cuellar, he looked solid in the pre-season games against Ajax and Chelsea, and the fact of the matter is Gers haven’t conceded in 5 games this season so far due to his work rate with Weir.
I know my post is biast against my team, but thats a fans view, perhaps in future in might be better tan what you have stated, being an Arsenal fan as your post says.
Cheers mate.
Scottie.[/quote]
Thanks for your constructive criticism. Arsenal are just my English team - I am actually Scottish but you can only select English teams on here as your favourite. I am a fan of an SPL club (I’ll not say which) and have a season ticket so I do see a lot of SPL football.
The one to watch was intended for young players - I’m well aware of Cuellar and I think he will be
one of the players of the season this year on his first few performances.
These predictions are just what I think - I’ll probably be well off the mark at the end of the season. If you want to write something about your own team then go for it - the site are always looking for new people to write stuff.
Thanks,
Craig
craig - August 17th, 2007 at 11:28 pm
Scottie - thanks a lot for the constructive criticism. I am actually Scottish - Arsenal are just my English club (you can’t choose a Scottish club as your favourite) - and I have a season ticket for an SPL club.
I’m well aware of Cuellar and I think he could turn out to be one of the players of the season based on his first couple of performances - however the one to watch was intended for young players.
You make a lot of good points in your posts - why not try writing something about Rangers or another SPL matter and send it in to the site. The site is always looking for people with intelligent views to write stuff.
Thanks,
Craig
craig - August 18th, 2007 at 12:12 pm
Sorry about the double post - I didn’t think it had worked first time.
Graeme - August 18th, 2007 at 3:49 pm
Motherwell to finish last after fighting with St. Mirren and Gretna?
Have you seen any football this season? Gretna are a long, long way of the SPL standard and St. Mirren don’t look up to much either.
I haven’t seen any interview with McGhee sounding arrogant, but if you can point me to them I may stand corrected. Even if he does, I’ll tell you one thing: He has the substance behind the ‘arrogance’. At Love Street on the opening day of the season, the Motherwell team came out and looked fitter, sharper and stronger than I’ve ever seen them on an opening day. We’re playing one touch football and scored as good a goal as I’ve ever seen a Motherwell team score.
I’m tempted to say I think a top six finish is on, probably a bit much, but we’ll be well clear of relegation.
craig - August 18th, 2007 at 7:54 pm
[quote comment=”55692″]Motherwell to finish last after fighting with St. Mirren and Gretna?
Have you seen any football this season? Gretna are a long, long way of the SPL standard and St. Mirren don’t look up to much either.
I haven’t seen any interview with McGhee sounding arrogant, but if you can point me to them I may stand corrected. Even if he does, I’ll tell you one thing: He has the substance behind the ‘arrogance’. At Love Street on the opening day of the season, the Motherwell team came out and looked fitter, sharper and stronger than I’ve ever seen them on an opening day. We’re playing one touch football and scored as good a goal as I’ve ever seen a Motherwell team score.
I’m tempted to say I think a top six finish is on, probably a bit much, but we’ll be well clear of relegation.[/quote]
The arrogance I’m referring to is his comments about not being offered jobs up here before.
He said about there being jobs available at Hearts and Aberdeen and he thought he should have been offered them.
I wrote a lot of this before the season started - Motherwell won their first 2 games against lesser teams and did well, but lost today against Killie. I’ll stick by my prediction just now, but I might be proved very wrong.
Anonymous - August 19th, 2007 at 10:53 am
This is the career progression of the semi-decent scotish footballer:
1) Start at local club
2) Move to rangers or celtic
3) Move to premiershipfor real football
4) Move back to ranger or celtic as the premiership was too tough!
darkblue62 - August 19th, 2007 at 11:25 am
Anonymous, you missed out on Nos 5,6,7
Instead of putting Scottish football or any other football down remember the majority of the best players in English football are foriegn.
5) Move into management
6) Take over at premiership club as English players cant hack the pressure and manage them.
7) Compare Hoddle/ Hodgekins/ Robson with Ferguson/ Moyes/ Graham/ Dalgliesh/ Souness
Phil - August 20th, 2007 at 1:39 pm
SPL?
Who Cares?