7 Reasons why Americans SHOULD like Soccer
by Mr Comfort on August 6th, 2008With David Beckham trying, and to some extent failing, to excite the masses into a fervour over the lovely game of Football, here are SEVEN reasons why the U S of A really should give the game a chance!
Don’t forget to check out Online Football Manager!
Every mention of football has been changed to soccer in order to further appease the American market!
7) Soccer manages to not pander to advertising overload, sure the game is getting more attuned to the money machine but at least it doesn’t break every few seconds for some words from our sponsors. Surely Americans are sick and tired of the constant breaks of play, be it for an inning break or timeout.
It begs the question, do the big sports in the US do so well because of the constant stop start nature of the games or are they just big because advertising has helped finance their success. The old chicken and egg syndrome if you like.
6) 2002! The USA’s performance at the World Cup in Japan and South Korea should have been the springboard to success for the sport. The achievements of that side should not be undersold. Bruce Arena’s side were not expected to progress from their group stage but started with a bang, going 3-0 up in the first half hour of their match against Portugal they then battled past Mexico in the second round and were extremely unlucky to lose to the Germans in the Quarters a result that really didn’t reflect the American’s superiority a point echoed by German legend Franz Beckenbauer who said, “America were clearly the better team for 90 minutes.”
It’s worth noting that had they triumphed over Rudi Voller’s side they would have probably eased past South Korea and found themselves in a World Cup final against Brazil!
5) It sounds like an old cliché, but Football really is a sport that unites all. It’s a sport that needs little in the way of finance to play. No need to buy a baseball bat and a mitt, or steel platted armour and also no need to be Eight foot tall to be any good at. All you need is a sphere shaped object, like a football, and you’re away!
4) 1950! If ever there was an awe inspiring shocking triumph of the human spirit an effort of David vs. Goliath proportions that should have shot the sport of Soccer into the national consciousness then that should have been it. The moment that the US beat an English team who were thought of as the best in the world was best summed up by American defender Harry Keough who said “Boy, I feel sorry for these bastards. How are they ever going to live down the fact we beat them?”
3) Soccer is simply far more entertaining that any other sport in the world. Why, I hear you ask? Well it’s the world’s most popular sport, simple. As a sport it is far less predictable than most. It’s a sport where upsets can and do occur on a regular basis.
2) The US has already proven how they are number one, or close enough, in the big four sports they love (American Football, Baseball, Basketball and Ice Hockey) and soccer could be their next big challenge? A country the size of the US, and it’s big, should really be much better than it is in the field of soccer. Sure the MLS is getting bigger and crowds are increasing but it really hasn’t exploded but if it did, boy would it make a big bang!
1) Everyone on the planet loves Soccer, not just one nation. Therefore when soccer (I mean football of course) plays its World Series (or World Cup as we call it) it really does include the WHOLE world and not just one nation. The game of football is played by more worldwide than any other sport (unless you count fishing which surely can’t be considered a sport) so surely the US would love to join the footballing family and attempt to conquer the world!



Stevzie - August 6th, 2008 at 12:56 pm
I am an american who loves the game but your selling points were kind of weak.
Frank - August 6th, 2008 at 12:57 pm
Good points, not sure Americans really need another sport to follow as they are already obsessed with the big FOUR
Crazy Canuck - August 6th, 2008 at 1:07 pm
Just so you know… Canada is the number one country in Ice Hockey.
Jeremy - August 6th, 2008 at 1:14 pm
To Crazy Canuck, in the piece it does say near enough number one in the top four sports in the US so he isn’t saying the US is number one in Ice Hockey.
max - August 6th, 2008 at 1:23 pm
i’d like to be nice, but these points show a certain ignorance about the situation of American Soccer.
1) we call it soccer because we already have a sport called football. If I call it football, people don’t know what I’m talking about so I don’t.
2) I’d argue the MLS is in very good shape. I attend just about every DC United game (I have season tickets) and every game, regardless of the opponent has 20,000 fans. That’s more than Portsmouth and Wigan average.
3) To say that David Beckham hasn’t worked is just not true. When he came to DC, there were 40,000 fans at the game, double the normal amount. Games that David Beckham plays either sell out in smaller stadiums, or get close to sell outs in large stadiums, eg. RFK Stadium fits 45,000 so they almost sold out
Craig - August 6th, 2008 at 1:30 pm
To Max, i take your points on board, but i think it is still fair to say that David Beckham’s impact on the MLS in no way mirrors the cost. I also think it is unwise to use big name stars to promote the league, the MLS needs to be wiser in its investments otherwise the league could head for bankruptcy once again. I think the point about 2002 is very valid also, what America achieved in that world cup has never really been championed.
J - August 6th, 2008 at 1:34 pm
I’m an American and I absolutely love football. Honestly though, the single biggest complaint I hear from people that don’t like the beautiful game is that there’s just not enough scoring, and to them that means it’s boring. To me, the fact that a game can change at any moment is part of what builds the tension and excitement of football.
I would say the US more accurately has the big 3, as the NHL doesn’t really have that much appeal to most people (once again, low scores = boring). MLB, NBA, and the NFL all have plenty of offense and the popularity to boot.
I would like nothing more than for soccer to be huge in the US, but it’s nowhere to close to becoming a reality.
Magnakai.Haaskivi - August 6th, 2008 at 2:33 pm
I agree with Craig; using former stars in bigger leagues is a poor way of promoting your league. American soccer needs to grow their own talent in order to be competitive.
And, really, while FANS like that there are less ads, ESPN doesn’t; that means less money for them, which means less coverage. There’re very few other outlets for sports, and the only league I’ll be able to follow stateside is the Premier League.
A bigger problem is the culture of soccer here in the U.S.; we concentrate on winning at the early levels way too much. Winning’s important, but when you’re young and don’t know the fundamentals of ball movement, ball skills, passing, trapping, or field vision it’s irrelevant if you can win a game on some fluky long ball goal. Soccer requires patience…and Americans generally don’t have that with their sports. The constantly moving clock (without the stop/start nature of American football, baseball, and even basketball) means you’ve really gotta watch 45 minutes of action; sadly, a lot of Americans really have no patience for that.
Incidentally…where can I watch Liverpool games this season in Cleveland?
Yank - August 6th, 2008 at 4:11 pm
I too am an american that really enjoys the EPL. (Spurs supporter, sadly)…
Here are the main reasons it is not big in the U.S.:
1. The “Big 3 (or 4) have a strangle hold on the sporting schedule. Whether you like it or not, the MLS is competing with the other sports for viewership and entertainment dollars. An uphill battle.
2. Advertising revenue. The first point made above about not pandering to advertising overload is a critical fault. Have you ever watched television in the U.S.? Advertising up the wazoo! That’s how the bills get paid. Soccer has no stoppages aside from halftime. Not enough $ rolling in. And to J’s comment about ESPN above… ESPN has been one of the biggest supporters of the sport. They regularly devote a good deal of time to covering US soccer on their broadcast, online and even in their magazine.
3. All the claptrap about soccer uniting the world is not a selling point. We’re talking about the USA here. We revel in being different from the rest of the world. Sadly, I’d venture to guess that 75% of Americans couldn’t pick England out on a world map.
4. A couple of points were made about how the US has done well at some recent and not so recent World Cups. Until the U.S. wins the World Cup, Joe Sixpack won’t lift an eyebrow… and even that is debatable. Americans have a complex about being #1 at everything and in many (most) people’s eyes, as long as we are losing to Poland and Portugal at something, it’s un-American.
5. Point number 3 above is highly debatable. I love soccer. I also love baseball. In fact I didn’t realize how much I liked baseball until a British friend tried to introduce me to cricket (snore). Regardless, comparing sports is like comparing cuisine. How do you compare a burrito to a curry?… sorry this is off topic.
Soccer is slowly getting more popular in the U.S.. More kids play it than any other youth sport and the MLS is gaining momentum. It will never be the most popular sport in the country, but I’m sure we’ll be good enough to kick England’s ass any year now. BANG!
Bob_Bobson - August 7th, 2008 at 1:03 am
good article & even better, well thought out responses
well done guys, pity most of the rest of the responses on this site aren’t as reasoned
in New Zealand we have a similar issue whereby rugby is by far the biggest game & if someone mentions “footy” it’s generally about rugger
Is it possible that American sports fans are conditioned to the multiple add breaks in the other sports?
(trying to resist the urge to say something about heading to the fridge…)
D-Train - August 7th, 2008 at 3:05 am
Outside of America, it is understood that soccer will not become huge in the USA because it doesn’t have the stop start nature to allow lots of advertising.
Jeremy - August 7th, 2008 at 3:09 am
In regards to your “chicken and egg syndrome”, the answer is very likely that because of the lack of commercials, television stations don’t want to carry soccer. It’s not much of a money maker, with so few commercials during the game, especially when you look at football and basketball. That’s probably the biggest barrier to soccer really catching on in America.
The second biggest barrier is the language issue… everybody else calls it “football”, while we have a very different sport in mind. This language barrier is a much bigger issue than it might seem…
Though I must say, it does seem to be catching on a bit. It’s one of those generational things… younger people seem to be slightly more interested now, which should pick up over the years.
johanssont - August 7th, 2008 at 3:11 am
The only thing wrong with Soccer is the people that play it. I would watch if there were 22 vinny Jones on the field, maybe 21 jones and 1 Paul Gascoigne. Seriously, hockey has been fairly effective at getting the diving out of the game, why can’t soccer. Those flopping fairies make it unwatchable.
Mike C. - August 7th, 2008 at 3:32 am
Soccer is great for the reasons listed but…
the problem with the game is how so much of the penalties are dictated by players’ acting skills in terms of getting the ref to call penalties.
Jim Dosser - August 7th, 2008 at 3:33 am
Sorry dude, Soccer is still a chicks game!
JT
Ultimate Anonymity
Jevan - August 7th, 2008 at 3:40 am
Honestly, the commercial thing is an easy fix. They should just do what they do with car racing which is have a split screen for commercials. It seems to work fine there. I don’t see the problem using it with soccer.
David - August 7th, 2008 at 3:43 am
1. Why is it that when people try to explain why soccer is not popular in the US it has to do with some perceived collective character flaw of Americans? I don’t really have anything against soccer, I just never cared for the sport. Does that make me some intellectual lightweight or someone with ADD? Does the fact that the rest of the world does not care about American football mean they are simpletons for not understanding the complexities of offensive and defensive schemes? If you like soccer, more power to you. I just don’t think there is anything with the American public refusal to embrace soccer. I don’t think having a preference of one sport over another has anything to do with mental capacity or character.
Soccerfan - August 7th, 2008 at 3:47 am
For #7 you say we don’t pander to advertisers….. We have a team named the “New York Red Bulls”. I mean, seriously?
tommmm - August 7th, 2008 at 3:47 am
The problem with soccer is there are no breaks for advertising.
This means soccer will NEVER be on mainstream US tv because the networks (and thus the teams and then the players) cannot make any money except for ticket sales and endorsements.
Soccer is the worlds most popular sport because tv is not supported entirely by advertising in most of the world.
If soccer would stop every few minutes for an advertising break, it could explode. Kids in the US play from childhood, but they never get to see good play on TV like the rest of the world does.
tenio - August 7th, 2008 at 3:48 am
@Jevan
thats a great idea
Sam A - August 7th, 2008 at 3:48 am
Just a quick point that most soccer fans know. The term “soccer” is from England, from “Association Football” to differentiate it from Rugby when the two sports’ rules separated. Don’t blame us Americans for simply continuing to use the English term.
Regarding the other points: wait a generation. The sports’ newsrooms are still populated by the good ol’ boys who grew up playing the Big 3 sports. But Yank is absolutely correct. According to the US Sports Marketing Association, more American children play soccer than baseball and football, combined! Since they’re already priced out of pro Football and bored with baseball (since they haven’t played it), when they’re running the newsrooms, we’ll hear about and see more about soccer…and football around the world.
Stuart - August 7th, 2008 at 3:49 am
I moved from the UK to the US and I’m convinced the reason soccer has done so poorly in the US is because of NTSC TV sets .. not enough definition to make out the individual players makes the game pretty poor to watch. HDTV I hope, will make a BIG difference by the time the next world cup rolls around.
stevo - August 7th, 2008 at 3:52 am
Not that I care at all, because I’m a baseball guy, but I think the primary reason soccer will continue to struggle in popularity here is that our best athletes play the big 3 homegrown sports because that’s where the (most) money is. Additionally, we have a jaded superpower = superiority complex and feel we don’t need to prove ourselves in that silly little game that the rest of the world plays. Plus it requires running around for 90 minutes and not using your hands.
rj - August 7th, 2008 at 3:58 am
1)Playing soccer is fun, But watching….YAWWWWNN.
2)2004 was setup in a bizarre way, I remember much of the rest of the world wondering why it was the U.S. got the seat it did. My guess Money.
FIFA would like nothing better than the U.S. to start dumping money into their coffers.
3)Simple is right… too simple.
4)Racism. Does it exist in the U.S. no question. But I’ve never seen it in a live or televised game (baseball, football…etc)like it occurs in soccer. Last thing I want to see is a U.S representative getting bananas chucked at him while he’s playing.
5) Why? why would it matter that the U.S. is not interested in Soccer? I don’t care if the rest of the world plays baseball or not. I don’t care if they play basketball. What is the motivation to get us all excited about this sport. We have a team, enjoy it, but leave the rest of us alone. When you get France to adopt English as its national language and the Republicans to adopt reason and compassion I will consider soccer.
Miguel Sanchez - August 7th, 2008 at 3:59 am
I’d add another reason
- The infrastructure in US Soccer has the potential to produce a team that will reach the world cup final within 10-20 years I think. I’m saying this as a Mexican soccer fan that has seen the US become the most powerful team in the CONCACAF in the last half decade (consistently beating Mexico). I believe this improvement will continue until the US team becomes one of the best in the world, surprising many many fans in the soccer loving world. It would be a shame for all this to happen when the country’s own fans are oblivious to the achievement.
Y.N.W.A. - August 7th, 2008 at 4:05 am
I’m sorry, but you really shouldn’t call it “soccer”. If there’s one thing that gets any British fan’s goat it’s Americans saying “SA-ker”. Call it football, and call that made up nonsense with the shoulderpads sommat else, and we’ll all feel a little less hostile to the idea of Americans playing football. (foot+ball = football, shoulderpads+rugby minus forward pass rule = something else)
Jaym - August 7th, 2008 at 4:17 am
It’s called “soccer” because it comes from associated rules football, whereas American football comes from gridiron rules football. Americans have heard the term “gridiron” in reference to football, but most don’t know where that came from. As to soccer, it’s a simple lazy conversion of “associated”… “assoc”… “soccer”. I kid you not!
I tend to love most sports, but soccer is one I’ve never gotten into- I feel it’s like hockey in most principles, but where hockey is fast paced with brutal hits and a small playing surface where things can change in a split second, soccer is on such a large pitch that the action always seems slow… and of course contact after a certain degree brings penalties and stoppage, which combined with the constant stop/start of play with the ball going out of bounds just seems to bog things down more.
Plus, with so many players on the field it’s hard to bond to them- you lose track easily. Hockey, with so few players on the ice and team, allows you to really know every player just like basketball or american football.
Again, this is just my personal reasons why I don’t enjoy soccer much. I see it as an inferior form of hockey.
ILM - August 7th, 2008 at 4:27 am
“Sport passion” is about culture. It is about history. You support the same team of your father, of your best friends. If I grow up watching baseball games on TV, or going to basketball games with my cousins, I will probably be an adult in love to these games. Americans loving soccer? I don’t think so… it is like Indians loving soccer, it will never happen.
kovosoccer - August 7th, 2008 at 4:34 am
I like to motivation behind the piece. I agree, the sport is trully awesome.
Roger - August 7th, 2008 at 4:45 am
They don’t pander to the advertising overload if you overlook the moving billboard that is every teams uniform!!
Notice that american football, baseball, basketball, hockey and other sports that are more popular don’t have advertisements on their uniforms. It is just a different way of pandering but don’t kid yourself, it is there in all “for profit” sports.
burwell - August 7th, 2008 at 4:52 am
what about the crowds in other world games. part of the fun about soccer is the energy the crowd has. few other sports have that! the entire stadium is chanting one or maybe two team songs! that is why soccer here hasnt picked up, because people havnt realized the fun just being in the crowd at a game.
Lonie - August 7th, 2008 at 4:55 am
FSC!… I am an American. I can sit and watch a large patch of green grass on television with a ball moving around and players shifting positions for hours. The incredible physical skill of these players is sometimes lost on a single point of reference camera angle zoomed out to catch the entire half in play though. I think that with American football style camera angles the sport would benefit greatly for American fans, however, the sport is far too unpredictable to allow for the scripted nature of TV presentation as takes place with basketball or football. I really find those sports extremely mundane. Any one who watched Turkey play in Euro 2008 knows how amazing this sport can be. Whatever you want to call it.
Anonymous - August 7th, 2008 at 4:57 am
Americans don’t include other nations in their world cups because its pointless.. all the other countries would just lose in the first round.. so we are just cutting out the middle man
Soccer is like riverdance, you are onto something, but you forgot about the other half of your body
If “the whole world” loves soccer, and the US is “so big,” but soccer isn’t big here, you obviously have some flawed statistics.. and the US is big.. so you figure out the rest
Leigh - August 7th, 2008 at 5:02 am
I stopped reading at number 1. Check out the kit/jersey of any professional soccer team. How big is the name of the sponsor in relation to the name of the team?
Bob - August 7th, 2008 at 5:04 am
Truly a world sport, but an extremely booooring sport to watch. Can you say World Cup finale ending 0-0 in Alatana a few years ago, and settled by kicks at the end. What a waste of time to watch. Make the goals bigger, or have a couple goal posts, or something to make this monstrosity of a sport more exciting.
Zach - August 7th, 2008 at 5:24 am
Soccer sucks. America is Football and baseball.
Anon - August 7th, 2008 at 5:36 am
American Football has an advantage in gaining a larger audience in the U.S., because there are many intermediate measures of sucess besides just scoring, such as, 4 downs to make 10 yards of progress or the ball is turned over to the other side. Also, the intricacies of advanced offensive and defensive plays are much more interesting than watching a bunch of guys run around kicking a ball toward this gigantic hockey type net guarded by none other than a “goalie”. Fancy footwork, alone, is not enough to keep my attention very long, sorry to say.
To me, Soccor is one of the most boring sports to watch, comparable to golf and curling.
Zach - August 7th, 2008 at 6:23 am
I’m sorry, but soccer is just plain boring. Even the most exciting soccer match I’ve ever seen (Chelsea vs Manchester Untied) made me want to tear my eyes out when a good two hours in to the game, the score was 1-1. I’ll grant that the shootout finish was thrilling, but it’s painful to watch a two hour bore-fest be decided in 20 minutes of penalty kicks.
Upsets happen in any sport. Look at Stanford’s upset of USC this past season. That knocked the socks of many a fan.
Advertising fits around American sports, not the other way around. Football and basketball (I don’t watch baseball, I find it as insipid as soccer if not more so) don’t stop games for commercial breaks. Stations fill in down time with commercials. An upside: some of the most entertaining advertising spots come from the marketing appeal of sports (superbowl commercials, anyone?).
Also the argument that soccer takes less to play doesn’t hold up. My friends and I played football with a tennis ball on a grass field in middle school.
Who knows, maybe soccer isn’t popular in America because so many children learn to detest the sport when their parents make them play in youth leagues like AYSO.
Jason - August 7th, 2008 at 7:03 am
In response to everyone “refuting” the advertising point by saying “look at the jerseys- it’s a moving billboard” etc., you’re missing the point. It’s television coverage that will grow the sport of football for the general public, and with no stoppages in play, the TV carriers aren’t bringing in enough money.
GL - August 7th, 2008 at 7:15 am
I’m an American living overseas and I can tell you that trying to watch soccer completely SUCKS.
Let’s face it.
American Football is a pure example of what American Culture is.
It’s bigger then anything out there in terms of raw power, strategy thinking, and the huge money and resources that are put into it.
Soccer is popular in the world because it’s a poor kid’s sport.
You only need a single ball to play it and even when it goes to the pro level it doesn’t require much more.
Football can also start with a single ball but in order to scale to any decent competitive level requires enormous resources, backing, organization, infrastructure and MONEY to get it done.
How much does it cost to fully equip any high school football team vs. some village soccer squad?
People this is the same reason why no other country has gone to the moon in the last 4o years..
Let me further illustrate my point here.
Watch the difference between a Soccer and a Football coach on the sidelines.
The soccer coach is essentially just another spectator with nothing to do… but he tries his hardest to look serious and important.
The football coach is wired with his headset and has a playsheet in his hand with 500+ plays. He’s supported by Defensive and Offensive coordinators monitoring the game from above the stands in a high tech war room of video equipment and computers.
This my friends is America.. and the frankly the rest of the world doesn’t have a chance.
This post was completely LAME because the author wants American’s to conform to “what the rest of the world enjoys”. That would be like asking a teenage boy to play barbies with the little girls.
Sorry guys.. ain’t going to happen.
American’s will continue to completely IGNORE soccer for many good reasons.
Let the rest of the world catch up to us and learn how to play football..
Instead of the other way around..
Anonymous - August 7th, 2008 at 7:40 am
soccer sucks, get over it.
JB - August 7th, 2008 at 9:19 am
GL=McCain=Looooooooser.
American football sux. It’s boring boring boring. And because it’s an alleged “poor mans” sport it’ll never catch on in the United Ignorance of America?? You, my sad friend, are everything thats wrong with the world. Go back to your cave………
Jordan - August 7th, 2008 at 9:40 am
Did you steal this essay from a 6th grader or something? Your “supporting details” are all the same thing.
smokedgouda - August 7th, 2008 at 12:32 pm
Beckham is in every way a success. No player could come in and sell as many tickets, T-shirts and get as much publicity as he has. It’s your definition of success that is lacking. What did you expect, that in a year Beckham would put MLS on every TV set in the US and have us winning the world cup? Steady growth is the only way, and we’re achieving it.
JT - you are likely a fratboy doofus who is too overweight to see his own toes. Here’s my suggestion to you, go have another buffalo wing and STFU.
Ed - August 7th, 2008 at 12:55 pm
@GL - And you live abroad with this kind of jingoistic attitude?
Please do voice your opinions openly all around, so they can kick you backto the country you belong.
Dick D - August 7th, 2008 at 1:11 pm
Are you kidding me?!?! Soccer doesn’t have as many ads? Their jerseys are plastered with ads! Our “big four” keep ads off the players uniforms.
razor1000 - August 7th, 2008 at 1:23 pm
ok first of all i wana clear something up ok.
Its not football its FUTBOL! and another thing for your consideration is that futbol games have just as many ads in place as any other sport i’m so sick of baner being overlaid in the green and also those animations that are runned everytime theres a free kick or sometimes even at random intervals.
and during half time you get so many 30 second comercials its enough to send you into convulsions!
Shooter - August 7th, 2008 at 2:03 pm
Soccer sucks. You guys are fags. Go Jets!
josh - August 7th, 2008 at 2:04 pm
“It’s worth noting that had they triumphed over Rudi Voller’s side they would have probably eased past South Korea and found themselves in a World Cup final against Brazil!”
Hmm, that’s funny because if I remember correctly, the US and South Korea tied in the group stages 1-1. Furthermore, the ONLY reason USA advanced past the group stages is because Korea beat Portugal, otherwise they would’ve flown right back home the next day. Bruce Arena, the US coach, bought gifts for the entire South Korean team and coaching staff after the victory. “Eased” is a pretty strong word given the circumstances.
Bob Loblaw - August 7th, 2008 at 2:13 pm
I take it this was a response to my article “7 reasons Americans will never embrace soccer” http://www.athlists.com/?p=19
Thanks.
ILM - August 7th, 2008 at 2:38 pm
There is a main reason why US don’t like soccer: this game is more than just score. US culture is score, is “beat the other”. Score in soccer is the main objective, but it is not all. When you watch a soccer game with your friends, you talk about the players’ efficiency, attitude etc. This game gives you time to talk about those things. It is not US.
morethannoise - August 7th, 2008 at 3:16 pm
Although not at all a fan of soccer, I do believe it has its place. As it’s less popular than other sports in the US with less people playing and therefore less competition, it becomes an outlet for high school athletes to garner at least partial athletic college scholarships.
I respect the athleticism required to perform in this sport but I just don’t find it exciting enough for my tastes.
TikiTattoo - August 7th, 2008 at 4:17 pm
I’ve seen lists like this before. They usually have nice, round numbers… like 10. I’ve never understood the popularity of professional soccer, and I’m not surprised that you couldn’t come up with more than 7 reasons in the list.
Troy - August 7th, 2008 at 4:57 pm
The fact that we see a new list like this every week of “why Americans will never enjoy professional soccer” is a sign that slowly, Americans will enjoy professional soccer. It’s inevitable. The NHL is losing viewership and television contracts, there are a mindboggling 160 games per season in baseball, the NBA hasn’t been the same since Jordan, and you’re left with the NFL as the only sport soccer will not surpass.
lionheart - August 7th, 2008 at 5:18 pm
I don’t know if it’s true that American will NEVER enjoy professional soccer. It’s basically the only sport I can stand watching on tv … especially if David Beckham is involved.
Matt - August 7th, 2008 at 8:11 pm
I’m American. I love soccer (futbol). But you really didn’t make a good argument for why Americans should love soccer.
Points like “it’s the most entertaining sport”, are highly opinionated and thus not valid arguments. If you tied in the reason why you believe it’s entertaining (the continuous play, constant running, transitional attacking, how one mistake can lead to a goal and inevitably a match’s decision…) then this article might carry some good weight.
I fully agree with the argument that American’s should love soccer though. I agree furthermore that it is the most entertaining game to watch. And it most definitely is in the financial second division, if not third.
Upsets can and do occur constantly in plenty of different sports as well. And the USA is not tops in hockey, that’s the Eastern European nation’s spots (Czechs, Russians, etc).
Overall if I were an editor, I’d say these are some nice starting points, now write a first draft.
Matt - August 7th, 2008 at 9:04 pm
Americans don’t like soccer for a few reasons. First - it is a game for little kids. We Americans all play soccer in grade school because there is little risk of getting hurt. We then graduate to American football when we get a little bigger. Second - the soccer players act like a bunch of weak little girls. For example - I was watching a European soccer game and noticed that the players frequently go down on a slide tackle, get carried off the field on a stretcher, and then they miraculously heal in 10 minutes and are back in the game. With any American sport - if a player gets carried off the field on a stretcher they will not be coming back. We don’t fake our injuries and the fans don’t want to see a bunch of pansies that fake injuries in order to get some rest. Finally - the games are too long and don’t have any breaks. We enjoy our time-outs and commercial breaks so we can get another beer or take a leak.
Dan - August 7th, 2008 at 10:16 pm
Even if a billion people believe in a dumb idea, it’s still a dumb idea. Most of those arguments are weak and why do you care if Americans like your boring sport or not? You could use most of your arguments for other sports like cricket, but it doesn’t change anything.
Magnakai.Haaskivi - August 7th, 2008 at 10:25 pm
It’s amazing how many anti-soccer Americans are lurking around on an English Premier League gossip site. For a sport you don’t claim to care about, you sure do spend a lot of time trolling.
Maurice Hilarius - August 7th, 2008 at 10:47 pm
It is pretty simple:
Americans will not be interested in a sport where they can not dominate and usually win.
Examples include basketball, baseball, and American football.
Notice something here?
These are all essentially AMERICAN sports.
If they had to risk going against other countries, and often losing, it would not be popular.
Essentially nthey NEED the “We are number one!” to feel good.
If they are not #1, they make up something to allow them to be #1.
Iuri - August 8th, 2008 at 2:13 am
Well, I think that soccer for North-Americans is like watch Nascar instead of Formula-1. I don’t blame anyone, because you create your tastes since you are a kid, and they grew up enjoying Nascar, basketball, American Football, and the most boring game in the world: baseball. Seriously, maybe Cricket is more exciting game than baseball (for me, of course).
Ian - August 9th, 2008 at 2:30 am
It’s amusing at times hearing from Americans like Jim Dosser (number 15) who say “Soccer is still a chicks game!” The thing is why do American ‘Footballers’ need all that padding? I mean are they really frail?! Do they bruise easily?! Then there are the skin tight shorts they wear, I mean a guy must be gay to like looking at men wearing that!
Jay - August 17th, 2008 at 1:52 am
how can people say football is a chicks game and full of fairies? what about player like Emanuel Pogatetz the broke his nose, jaw and cheekbone in a tackle and was back in training in less than a month and he was also banned for 24 weeks by the russian football federation because he tackled Yaroslav Kharitonskiy leaving him with a double leg fracture
Jay - August 17th, 2008 at 1:59 am
@razor1000
it IS football in englsih
futbol is spanish
Antman - August 18th, 2008 at 6:48 am
Never say never. Australians are now fatter than Americans. Anything is possible.
GWheezy - August 28th, 2008 at 8:09 pm
I think anyone who is American…Like ME…Would totally embrace soccer or football (I WILL GET TO LATER) if the rest of the world would stop being pussy’s. American’s play the game rough, like men, cause they are. Europeans dive clear as day as if the were a leaf in a hurricane. Then they lay there waiting for the med staff and trainer to prance over and spray the magic fairy dust. RIDICILOUS….Just goes to show Europeans like always have no shame or integrity. Spreaken si Deutch??? Well you would have, if it hadnt been for us. So now back to the name thing. American Football as much as I love it…GO BEARS….should be the one changed. Most easiest for everyone. They were forced to change that bullshit wrestling thing from federation to entertainment since its not a sport, but then again the UEFA Champions League should be renamed to Champions entertainment for all the acrobatic rolls and flips.
Average American - August 30th, 2008 at 12:47 am
Sawker sucks as do people who aren’t american. Non-Americans are inferior to americans. Sawker is an inferior culture that is threatening to take over america as it is shoved down our thoats by inferior global elite foreigners.
USA USA USA!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!! SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!SAWKER SUCKS!!!
SAWKER SUCKS!!!
Andy - August 30th, 2008 at 10:13 pm
Hey, an Englishman here. Just saying that Football (soccer) is brilliant, does anyony remember the Champions League Final between Liverpool and AC Milan? H/T Milan lead 3-0. F/T Liverpool pull it back to 3-3, (I wen’t nut’s) During which our Polish ‘keeper Jerzy Dudek made a world-class save from Andriy Shevchenko, he knew nothing about it, i actually soiled myself
Anyway, Liverpool won it on penalties, so a great comeback was complete, you don’t get that in any other sport, just amazing.
It is truly a worldwide sport, Liverpool from England, Milan from Italy, playing each other in Istanbul, Turkey.
You don’t have to like Football, it’s a choice thing, i hate Cricket and Rugby, there terrible, but know one whinges at me, so decide for yourselves what sport you wan’t to follow. Cheers.