“We were robbed against Liverpool” claims Wigan manager: Is he right?
by stresster on October 19th, 2008The Latics were 2-1 up in the 75th minute at Anfield on Saturday, when Antonio Valencia unwisely decided to lunge at Xabi Alonso and earn a second yellow card for his troubles. As we all know, Liverpool went on to win the match 3-2, and while Rafael Benitez denied that the dismissal changed the match, his opposite number was fuming by the final whistle!
The Press Association reports that Steve Bruce is not a happy bunny, especially with the midfielder getting a first yellow card for being part of a wall that wasn’t getting back ten yards. However, the Ecuadorian’s challenge on Alonso might have merited a straight red anyway. Nevertheless, you can understand why the Wigan manager has spat his dummy after seeing his team lead twice.
“The referee got the first booking for Valencia wrong,” said Bruce. “The Liverpool player took the kick, and Valencia did not encroach towards it until the ball had been kicked. So he got that one wrong. Then there is the tackle on Alonso, in which I felt the lad touched the ball. I felt that was harsh.
“In my opinion we were robbed. It is a joke that we have not come away from this match with something,” he added. “Those decisions changed the whole course of the game. With 11 against 11 we would not have lost. But there were a lot of tired bodies out there and we could not hold out.”
Does Bruce have a point or is it just sour grapes from the Wigan manager? After all, Agger gifted Zaki the first of his goals, and Liverpool were starting to threaten before Valencia got his marching orders. Do Reds fans think that they were lucky to get the three points on this occasion?
Discuss the latest transfer gossip at the Brand New COS forum!


Mikey Boy - October 19th, 2008 at 4:06 pm
Moan Moan Moan -
A game lasts 90 minutes+, by the 50th minute Wigan looked knackered. It was only a matter of time before Liverpool would score a few goals. So although the sending off may have helped, Liverpool were already in the ascendency and Wigan had no fight left.
Besides for a player on a yellow to make such a rash tackle right in front of the referee just shows how tired he was or how stupid he was.
So stop crying Bruce and get yourself a fitness coach who can get your players to play for a full game not just one half.
Bill - October 19th, 2008 at 4:12 pm
Antonio Valencia was using tackles that would have had him sent off in a rugby league game never mind a football match, You can’t go around throttling people for 90 mins without atracting cards. He was on Alonsos case from the start,
browny - October 19th, 2008 at 4:23 pm
Chelsea had 70 % poss and about 14 shots max… they won 5-0
Liverpool had 68% Poss and 17 shots… so were Wigan lucky?? It works both ways Bruce…
I will give him that it was looking like they would get the points / 1 at least, because we were not taking our chances (again) but then..we did. End of!
Donavan Ried - October 19th, 2008 at 4:50 pm
I think that the ref go it right, but i can see where Bruce is coming from…. the refs are to Inconsistence …… I think if they booked more players for Encroachment ( Thats not being the right distance away) this would not happen
The tackle was just crazy
Heres one that I would like too see brought in …….. If you commint a blatant red card offence which is not caught by the ref/lines men during the match (say a player punches another or stamps on him) because it would effect the out come of the game; then the ref should be able at the start of the next game before the kick off to go up to that player and show him a red card reducing his side to ten….. Would make players think before comminting off the ball Incidences
jonesy wafc - October 19th, 2008 at 5:17 pm
well the tackle that valencia made my of been a bad challange but 5 mins after he got sent off alonso made an worse challenge and didnt evan get yelloewd i have to go to liverpool and get stuck in to them but the ref didnt let us do that and therfor spoild the game weellll donee reeffff !!
King Kong - October 19th, 2008 at 5:29 pm
Red card? yes
Robbed? nope
Bruce right? only his comments on Zaki was
Wigan naive? 2-1 winning at Anfield, ball in LFC half, lunging “leg breaking” tackle on Alonso when you have a yellow…yes
ISA - October 19th, 2008 at 7:54 pm
FUCK YOU>……LIVERPOOL ARE THE CHAMPIONS FOR THAT TOU CAN NOT BEAT THEM WITH YOUR FUCKING WIGAN
9torres - October 20th, 2008 at 10:09 am
ISA is a twat…
9torres - October 20th, 2008 at 10:10 am
Constructive not Destr…Shit Chatting
adli - October 20th, 2008 at 10:24 am
never tackle alonso.
fans love him and refs love him too. red cards for tackles on him vs manure, vs city, vs toffees and now vs wigan.
alan B'stard M P - October 20th, 2008 at 10:59 am
he got sent off. He’s a twat. Also, any bastard who dives should be sent off immediately
RassHenry - October 20th, 2008 at 11:51 am
MR CHIEF EDITOR THERE IS ALWAYS STORIES ABOUT LIVERPOOL ,ARSENAL,SPURS ON THE SITE WHEN ARE U GOING TO TALK ABOUT A REAL TEAM LIKE MAN U & CHELSEA & MILAN
9torres - October 20th, 2008 at 1:27 pm
Are you insinuating that Liverpool, Arsenal and Spurs are merely fictional teams made up by Mr. Chris Toy and his staff, similar to Harchester??
Donavan Ried - October 20th, 2008 at 1:40 pm
RassHenry - October 20th, 2008 at 11:51 am …. Rasta it use to be that you go to the front page and click on your team….don’t know why they changed it ……. Type http://www.caughtoffside.com/tags/premier-league/man-utd or any other team you want or even Manchester united | caughtoffside …… peace and love Rasta
fordster - October 21st, 2008 at 9:16 am
The first yellow card should never have been given so therefore the second yellow card should have been his first. He moved out from the wall after the ball was touched which is the right thing to do, look at the replay and see for yourself. The ref pretty much ensured the game belonged to Liverpool.
9torres - October 21st, 2008 at 9:18 am
Second yellow could have been a straight red so i think it evens itself out. Any player on a yellow who makes such a ridiculous tackle deserves to be sent off.