“I’m not sure it was a penalty” admits Liverpool captain: Did he cheat to win the spot-kick?
by stresster on November 5th, 2008 17 commentsThe Reds are practically through to the Champions League knockout stages after a 1-1 draw with Atletico, although it appears they had to rely on a piece of gamesmanship to land a precious point on Tuesday night. The visitors looked to be on their way to a historic victory at Anfield, before a collision on the edge of the penalty area led to the referee blowing his whistle.
The Guardian reports that Steven Gerrard is far from sure that it was a definite spot-kick, although the vast majority of viewers would have been scratching their heads in disbelief after Martin Hansson awarded a penalty. Even if it was a foul by Mariano Pernía, surely the original offence was outside the area?
Gerrard had his reservations but denied the penalty was the result of any theatrics on his part. “I’m not sure it was a penalty. I got there first and I think if that is outside the area you get a free-kick,” the Liverpool captain said. “If it happened at the other end we would be livid. That’s football. It’s a point and we move on.”
Four Atlético players were booked in a chaotic aftermath while a Spanish journalist asked Javier Aguirre, the coach, whether the decision was evidence of a Uefa conspiracy to punish the club for recent crowd trouble at Vicente Calderón. “I didn’t see anything untoward going on at all,” side-stepped Aguirre, who was restricted to the stand for this game due to a Uefa suspension. “It is not my habit to talk about referees and I am not going to break that habit now.”
No wonder the Liverpool captain is so sheepish about the incident, after he practically threw himself on the Atletico defender in a last-ditch attempt to get something out of the match. Did the Reds deserve to land a draw, or have they been Luckypool once again?
Discuss the latest transfer gossip at the Brand New COS forum!
Related Posts:
‘We’re in good shape’ claims Liverpool manager after Everton defeat: Do supporters agree?




T - November 5th, 2008 at 10:31 am
I dont think it was but there was other incidents which didnt go our way so a little justice was done in the end.
9torres - November 5th, 2008 at 10:43 am
Yep, justice done, wasn’t a penalty but the missed handball was stonewall
Robbo1973 - November 5th, 2008 at 11:12 am
Another blatant dive from the games biggest cheat.
9torres - November 5th, 2008 at 11:15 am
United don’t play til tonight mate
Robbo1973 - November 5th, 2008 at 11:33 am
I think he’s a fabulous player, but lets himself down by going to ground too easily and too blatantly. He’s one of too many cheats in the game. What about Athletico’s two stonewall penalties?
JJ - November 5th, 2008 at 11:39 am
NEWSFLASH….all footballers dive!! cronaldo gerrard pires henry rooney eto’o messi drogba….
Robbo1973 - November 5th, 2008 at 11:45 am
Does that make it right then JJ?
9torres - November 5th, 2008 at 11:51 am
No, it does make it harder to compete though if you don’t take a foul when it’s due
D - November 5th, 2008 at 1:00 pm
Blantant dive, the defender was taken out and should have received a free kick. The ref though was a total failure, missing a handball penalty for pool and two for atl madrid. You could actualy see Steve’s plan when he chased towards the defender and that is what is the difference between this premeditated dive and the other divers in the world.
BringBackBananas - November 5th, 2008 at 1:11 pm
the difference is that this particular serial diver has gone on record several times saying he didnt agree with diving and as club captain would have a word with any of his squad that did
there are plenty of cheats in the game, but a cheat and a hypocrite also?
Yida - November 5th, 2008 at 1:14 pm
It has to be said that Steven Gerrard has become very adept at just running into people and claiming penalties/ freekicks. It’s not the conventional swallow dive that many other players adopt but it is equally effective.
martin - November 5th, 2008 at 3:05 pm
A good as any reason for using playback. Poor decisions will always be made by refs, but when certain players develop the ability to continually deceive officials, something must be done to counter this. In situations where a cheat affects the game’s outcome (like last night, where Atletico ended up with a point rather than 3) the offender and his club should be fined, as a deterrent, with the opponents being awarded the three points.
ronnie's shagging ronald! - November 5th, 2008 at 3:19 pm
Jealously has never looked good on anyone. What matters is the result and whether or not it was fair due to the performance and character of the players involved. Liverpool were denied 2 clear cut penalties, and Athletico were denied one clear cut penalty. Carragher could do nothing about the ball hitting his arm because the ball initially deflected off his knee. That in any case where the ref isn’t a complete retard (like some people on this site), would never be given as a hand ball because it was purely unintentional ball to hand.
With the Mascherano case for appeal, it would have been extremely soft had that been given, but in the past those type of scenarios have earnt penalties. However, they are completely 50-50 in the case of the game as a whole and the only real lee-weigh is dependent on the particular ref in charge of the match. Let me remind you that the linesmen in the match were also rubbish, failing to call correct corners and giving false corners.
In the end had Liverpool won it would have been unjust against an Athletico team which were well organized, had a clear strategy (playing on the counter) and played reasonably well with that in mind. Liverpool controlled almost all of the ball and conceding the goal was the only thing wrong they did all night. They played some of their best football to date and it would have seemed like injustice if they couldn’t get something from playing so well.
Although one thing is evident from last nights game; without Fernando Torres Liverpool will be no where near competitive enough to win anything this year. Let’s all hope Rafa makes a 25-goal-a-season top international striker with pace and age on his side in January. (i.e. Sergio “Kun” Aguero or David Villa)
fernando clarke - November 5th, 2008 at 3:57 pm
wise up u fukn united retards, gerrard biggest cheater in the game, dnt make me laugh lik lol if he ‘cheated’ do you think hed say ‘i dont know if it was a penalty’ just because you fall over and dont know if it was a penalty doesnt mean uv dived he got hit in the back and fell over! have any of you people played football and lost your balance before!? we should have won without the pen anyway!
EVERTON - November 5th, 2008 at 4:10 pm
the only man that i respect in liverpool(so is torres) did this….this is disgraceful and shameless for them…even if they(liverpool)lost that game,they still definitely qualify to knockout round….
BringBackBananas - November 5th, 2008 at 4:22 pm
are you suggesting gerrard lost his balance?
or that his theatrics and appeal weren’t an attempt to indicate to the referee he thought he was fouled?
Donavan Ried - November 5th, 2008 at 9:20 pm
Robbo1973 – November 5th, 2008 at 11:33 am …….”I think he’s a fabulous player, but lets himself down by going to ground too easily and too blatantly. He’s one of too many cheats in the game” ….. I have to agree with Robbo1973…It took the shine off of what would have been a good performance for me …….. Plus you run the chance of hurting you team if you have already been booked and pick up anotheryellow for diving….. said it before …I hate any player who has to cheat to win ….