Was it a barnstorming game or a damp squib? Who had a ‘mare’ and who was on the money? You decide with our lovely cut and paste thingy!

See below the line-ups, then simply give your personal rating for each player and cut and paste the whole thing into the comments box. Then see how your fellow fans scored the game.

Liverpool
Reina
Arbeloa
(Agger)
Carragher
Skrtel
Aurelio
Mascherano
Alonso
(Lucas)
Gerrard
(Ngog)
Kuyt
Riera
Torres

Aston Villa
Friedel
Reo-Coker
(Guzan)
Cuellar
Davies
Luke Young
Milner
Petrov
Barry
Ashley Young
Heskey
(Agbonlahor)
Carew
(Gardner)

Get a free £10 bet on Liverpool or Aston Villa by joining William Hill now.