Three In; Ten Out: Liverpool’s £75m Summer Transfers Analysed: Good Deals?
by YNWA on September 4th, 2009 824 words | 54 commentsIt’s been a long hard summer for Rafa.
In
Glen Johnson
Already proven himself to be a very effective attacking force and offers more than the steady but unspectacular Alvaro Arbeloa. Seemed pricey when initially purchased but seems like a very good transfer even after such a short spell, hopefully will get better and better.
Alberto Aquilani
Very hard to judge this transfer as the Italian is of course injured and could be out for some time longer. Whilst its probably not the best idea to purchase a player with a long term injury I trust that Rafa knows what he is doing on this one. Not a direct replacement for Xabi, kind of a mixture of Alonso and Javier. Handily a large portion of the transfer is in installments.
Sotiros Kyrgiakos
A no nonsense defender who should have “does exactly what is says on the tin” scrawled across his shirt. We know what to expect from the Greek veteran, a very able back up option and perhaps most importantly, a very cheap one.
Out
Paul Anderson
Talented young winger who could never muscle his way into the first team picture forced to find pastures new. General feeling appears to be that he was a damned quality player who just wasn’t given a chance to show his stuff, I predict he will bounce back to the Premier League sooner rather than later.
Sebastian Leto
Much publicised passport problems stifled his career at the club and the Argentine winger had no choice but to try his luck elsewhere. On the very rare occasions he did play for us he didn’t look that good. Now plying his trade with Panathinaikos and has started pretty well there.
Astrit Ajdarevic
Part of the Youth Cup Winning side of 2007 this lanky attacking midfielder went on loan at Leicester and clearly they liked what they saw as they took him permanently this summer. Never got near the first team picture at Anfield.
Jack Hobbs
Now when Jack first got involved in the first team picture he didn’t look very good. Quite an awkward style of footballer who never looked comfortable on the ball but he did manage to improve and got a few chances to prove himself but in the end moved on loan to Leicester and had a fantastic season playing virtually every game as the romped to the title. Has now made the move permanent and looks to have the potential to do very well in the game.
Sami Hyypia
Bowed out from the club with an emotional farewell against Spurs after ten years of dedicated service. 450+ appearances and umpteen medals. Great servant to the club moved to Bayer Leverkusen and has started all four of their opening Bundesliga games and the club remains unbeaten so clearly he still has the ability to be a rock in the centre of defence.
Jermaine Pennant
A player with talent who could have gone far with the club but was just far too much of a headache on and off the field. Long periods of poor form and an attitude problem that left Rafa with no choice but to use him very sparingly after his first season. Moved to newly promoted La Liga side Real Zaragoza but I would predict he will not be there for more than one year and probably far less.
Shane O’Connor
Irish teenager never got near the first team picture and must have found the prospect of playing under legend Roy Keane too much to turn down.
Alvaro Arbeloa
Went away to the Confederations Cup after the season came to an end and then watched on as Rafa bought a replacement in the form of Glen Johnson. From then on it was a matter of when and not if, he would leave. He got the move he craved as his former side Real Madrid came calling. The Spaniard did a good job for the club and was generally a very reliable player.
Xabi Alonso
A big loss to the club. Xabi was of course very close to being offloaded last summer and apparently since that point was thinking of leaving the club. The long drawn out saga with Real Madrid was tasteless and irritating as the Spanish giants did there best to unsettle the player and attempted to get him on the cheap. In the end we did well to get a good fee for him. Will surely do well at the Bernabeu. Gave some fantastic performances in a Liverpool shirt with last season probably the best of the five he spent at the club.
Adam Hammill
Hammill, like Anderson, was a player many Liverpool fans expected to make a name for himself at the club but like his fellow winger, spent much of his time at the club being loaned out gaining valuable experience but then never really given a chance in the first team. Moved to Barnsley but I am sure he will break back into the big time.
YNWA
Related Posts:
Revealed: Liverpool Boss Job Application Form









anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 2:05 pm
I think we did okay this summer, as well as could be expected in terms of funds
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 2:06 pm
Good solid analysis. Agree with your points. I saw Anderson play on loan in League One and he was fantastic. Should have got a decent shot, maybe even in the Carling Cup, but he got nothing.
Dom - September 4th, 2009 at 2:25 pm
After all the talk, the reality of our signings were very dissappointing. I’m depressed about the whole thing and Johnson is a waste of money. We’ve lost two games already and things can only get worse
footybanter.co.uk - September 4th, 2009 at 2:25 pm
Yes, very good analysis here. Hard to disagree with anything said on the whole and a good read.
I knew Leverkusen were doing well (I’ve had them in more than one acca already this season) but had no idea Hypia was there. Renewed my confidence in the team a bit.
Lincoln burrows - September 4th, 2009 at 2:30 pm
shame we didn’t manage to sign Villa. I’m surprised that we never pulled him off as he was at Liverpool so I guess he either wants to go else where or will sin in January – lets hope so!
Lincoln burrows - September 4th, 2009 at 2:34 pm
footybanter.co.uk – September 4th, 2009 at 2:25 pm
Your rival website is not welcome here… I call upon all present to ignore this imposter who is paid by footybanter.co.uk to advertise thier www via comments and other methods.
GO HOME YOU’RE NOT WELCOME HERE
Lincoln burrows - September 4th, 2009 at 2:36 pm
Dom – September 4th, 2009 at 2:25 pm
Agree with you mate – Alonso was a nightmare as it dragged on for so long. Think Masch will go next summer and we will need to sign big which I don’t think will happen while G&H are in charge.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 2:39 pm
Poor detail on Anderson and Hammill in my opinion, these guys will have been watched most if not all games last season to see how they were progressing. Reports are filled for referance (you know how maticulous Rafa is) and then desisions are made.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 2:44 pm
I to feel slightly disappointed with our activity in the transfer window this summer, Johnson is better than Arbeloa and has already scored more in the last few games than Xabi did all of last season. Kyrgiakos is an excellent replacement for Sami… Aquilani although brilliant when fit wasnt the greatest choice to help us hit the ground winning, i would have preferred Defour or Martinez as they would have made an immediate impact…. The greatest disappointment was not adding more depth to the squad (i feel we still need a natural right winger, a couple more striking options and another central midfielder). Although we didnt have a great amount of depth last year and still lead our best challenge for years – Im sure the boys will do us proud again this season! – YOU’LL NEVER WALK ALONE!!!
bod - September 4th, 2009 at 2:45 pm
Dom, how have you come to the conclusion that Johnson is a waste of money?? He’s been our best player in 2 of our opening games so far. I think he’s a great signing, who gives us an extra attacking dimension. He will be an important player in our bid to turn dour draws into wins. It’s a case of wait and see on Aquilani, but I’m sure he’ll do the business. At the end of the day, this current squad is what we have, so lets get behind them.
spike - September 4th, 2009 at 2:59 pm
good job coach………but we cud have got another midfield player and get rid of that shithound LUCAS
bod - September 4th, 2009 at 3:00 pm
Fair point, spike. I cant disagree with you on that one.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 3:04 pm
Rafa has done well with the money he has had available, although maybe opting for david silva instead of aquilani.
Who knows he could be a shrewd buy like alonso was, nobody had heard of him when rafa signed him.
NEED NEW OWNERS DESPERATE !!
if we had even £30million transfer budget on top of the incomings and outgoing players we could have had a better squad.
We should have got Owen on a free, just for depth to our poor strikeforce. We could have got Silva !! Turner and Cattermole as well, good up and coming english talent.
Realistically we need to sell:
Voronin
Babel
And replace them with:
Ashley Young or Becks on loan (piss off the mancs)
Joe Cole
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 3:27 pm
I agree with most comments here. When you don’t have the funds, what are you suppose to do? Johnson is a great signing and Aqualani is a very good player. I’m from Canada and we get a lot of Italian football on the telly over here. I’ve watched him play. He’s very good. How he adapts to the english game….. well, we’ll have to wait and see. He is a quality player though. LFC FOREVER.
Hoogleboogybugleboy - September 4th, 2009 at 3:33 pm
You forgot Chris Mavinga. He was bought from P S G in the summer. He is 18, is primarily a left back but can also play centre back. I don’t know the player but this is from the club website.
I think that Glenn Johnson will prove to be the best bit of business that Rafa has ever done. Aquilani is also a very good player. Remember, Arsenal tried to sign him either last summer or the one before but he wasn’t ready to leave Roma at that time. Wenger very rarely gets it wrong so that say’s a lot to me.
I would have liked us to have signed another top class attacking player but all in all I’m happy with thye summer’s business in the transfer market.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 3:36 pm
dom are you sure your not manure scum, pretending to be a RED. Your knowledge stinks. How can you say Johnson is waste of money when arguably he has been the best player for up, how many other right backs have scored two spectacular in four games, never mind the whole season.
spike - September 4th, 2009 at 4:02 pm
i gotta agree my fantasy football team has glen, gerrard and torres in it…………..
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 4:15 pm
spike,mine too………
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 4:29 pm
Why has Christopher Mavinga not been included in the ‘In’ section. I’ll tell you why, because you are just one of those shit heads who thinks he knows about football but really doesn’t. You know shit.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 4:41 pm
Rafa has funded his signings this season with the sales of alonso,arbeloa and fringe players.
What happened to the 15m we got back for keane in january and the 20m a season the yanks promised us every season before sales?
We should have 35m in the bank to spend on players still!
The yanks need to get out asap,broken promises!
Ash T - September 4th, 2009 at 4:47 pm
the problem with johnson is that when he goes forward, we are open in defence.
but when we get aquilani fit, hopefully he will be able to controle the game so the other teams dont have the ball to score with
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 4:55 pm
the signing we need is new owners someone loves the club
Warren Bloggs - September 4th, 2009 at 5:19 pm
In January Liverpool need to sign Rafael Van der Vaart and Fernando Llorente to improve our squad immensly!
Warren Bloggs - September 4th, 2009 at 5:26 pm
Ash T i understand what you say but i personally beleive once Aurelio, Agger, Skrtel and Aquilani are ‘fully fit’ then this ‘problem’ will cease. Unfortunaetely, Liverpool do not have the squad to handle such injuries, therefore we need someone like Van der Vaart in January along with a new striker such as Carlton Cole or Fernando Llorente of Bilboa. With these players we would be greatly improved. Lucas is decent but not good enough to play week in, week out. Sell Degen and sign Lucas Neill as cover, Sell Babel, Sell Voronin and give Darby, Spearing, Plessis, El Zhar, etc their chance. I will be greatly annoyed if Kristian Nemeth does not return next season and become a regular!
ps. Daniel Pacheco will shine at Liverpool fc and will prove to be world class given time!
John Conor - September 4th, 2009 at 5:27 pm
guys as fellow Liverpool supports i’d just like to know if any of you ever get lonely, and whether you’d like to catch up some time….im 3inches..i love long walks along the beach and i’m waiting to be swept off my feet by a like minded man from the merseyside area..any takers? remember guys, with me, You’ll Never Wank Alone
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 5:37 pm
i dont get it why did we sell leto he was amazing he could be one of our best youths i know he couldnt get a visa but still on loan till he could play for us better on the wing than anyone at his age definate
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 5:38 pm
There’s the problem. Most of the fans saying we must buy villa,silva and every other player plays fantasy football. Liverpool haven’t always been big spenders. Support the team and players that the manager has manage to aquire. And cool it on lucas. Despite the shitheads who boo him at anfield(which is not the Liverpool way) the kid still plays with all his heart. And yes he’s still a 22yr old kid.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 6:36 pm
What we need are natural wingers. WE NEED DAVID SILVA NEXT SUMMER and Maybe Lavezzi. We can sell reira, voronin, dossena and degan. Also get a cheap lb and some young players like de federico.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 7:21 pm
Dom you talk 5hit how can johnson be a waste of money when he’s already scored 2 goals and been our best player so far!
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 7:24 pm
off topic this im an avid liverpool fan and according to the papers 2day man u are supposed to be the richest club in the world at 1.3billion someone tell me how the fcuk that is when there 750m in DEBT twice as much as us! why is it these days its man u this man u that im sick of it its like there the only team in PL fcuk off! and drop dead sir alex!
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 7:28 pm
Rafa has to go he isnt good enough to manage LFC he hasnt got a clue!,what manager keeps playing shit like lucas,voronin,babel,ngog,dossena the list goes on there all 3rd rate players rafa is the one that should go to specsavers!?! he will never win us the PL he should go b4 he does more damage than he has already piss off u useless spanish lump!
Warren Bloggs - September 4th, 2009 at 7:37 pm
I would like these ‘anonymous’s’ to sign in so we can ALL see who they are it appears that all of these digs are given whilst hiding behind the smokescreen that is ‘anonymous’? As for the comment above i also agree that the likes of Lucas, Voronin and Dossena are clearly not good enough to be in our first team however they provide adequate cover and depth to the squad. Unfortunately, we do not have the kind of money to splash out on the likes of David Villa, Sergio Aguero or Franck Ribery! This is not Rafa’s fault is it, no the problem lies with our owners!
saif - September 4th, 2009 at 7:38 pm
good posts on here
by the way maybe rafa didn’t want to use up his entire transfer fund and maybe he wants peaople to think liverpool are penny less and by the way why aren’t eny one looking at man shit utd and theredept
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 8:07 pm
Utd may jus be the next club to receive a ban on sinings ! ! ! Apparently a few of their recent transfers have caused controversy with the smaller clubs they bought from, and complaints have been made. It appears that Arsenal and Liverpool may be safe from such a ban as they signings they have made have all been accepted by the origional club. How fucking sweet would it be if Chelski and Man Ure cant buy anyone for a year?!
Cant be fucked to sign in, posted By Vern Schillinger
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 8:32 pm
liverpool will get relagated i think wolves could possibly win i heard they could be bying Cammy Ward Anthony Smith ben corrall & Jacob Stephen
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 8:52 pm
doesnt understand what football is ^
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 9:00 pm
Alonso and Are going to be missed. Both will be hard to replace. The idea is to adapt to a new formation / strategy but due to our success last season we (the fans) have put a lot of pressure on the team to improve and get the title this season, the lack of Alonso and Arbela isnt helping the case as the other players we are looking towards arent nearly as good enough as they are.
Guillem - September 4th, 2009 at 9:25 pm
I don’t think we did bad guys. We have to remember that last year we were a few dodgy draws away from the title. All is not doom and gloom. We have replaced Arbeloa, a sterdy average full back with a machine. Johnson is basiacally a winger. I’ve never seen anything like it, for a wing back to score 2 goals in four games (good goals at that), is unheard of. He wont carry on with that rate but who cares, he gets up and down that line better than Valencia at United so I am sceptical of fans like Dom (who assured me Masch’s wife was taking him to spain) who can’t see his worth to the club.
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 10:10 pm
we miss a big chanse to sign david silva
anonymous - September 4th, 2009 at 11:34 pm
Talking about players for the future what about the young Lauri Dalla Valle he`s from Finland and iv seen him play for the youth team a few times and he’s got hat full of goals something like 14 goals in 22 games looks like a really good player for the future
GOOGLE HIM
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 3:25 am
i 100% agree on dalla valle. i follow the youth and ressies and dalla valle has wpic potential. great finishing, decent pace, intelligent and has scored at full international level at least once.
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 4:38 am
until aquilani is fit, we should bench lucas,replace him with stevie g,and play kuyt up front with torres.riera and benayoun have to be our wingers.without alonso’s passing ability stevie g is wasted up front.if torres gets injured we are fcked,cant believe we only have one genuine top class striker in our squad.allahs boot.
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 7:07 am
Leto was sold because he didnt have a work permit. He went to Greece last year on a 2 yr loan to get enough experience. he then had a bust up and I guess rafa thought ’sod it’ and cash in, rather than fart about with another loan.
baggins09 - September 5th, 2009 at 7:21 am
can people stop going on about villa & silva, at the end of the day they dont want to leave valencia and we can’t afford them.
im glad we bought johnson instead of silva he’s been awsome. hasn’t riera taken silva’s starting spot for spain anyway? and he’s not that amazing if it wasn’t for the fact he’s spanish no one would give a shit about him.
i would have rather got lavezzi for that sort of money who can cover both wings, “the gerrard role” as it is know known and play up to with torres or on his own and he would enhance nando’s game not hinder it like villa.
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 8:27 am
im very upset of the bad buzz that’s seems to be around the club as a hole at the moment? all the hype before the start of the season is gone backwards? but maybe a kick in the backside is what we need.. as for transfers i think we could have done better when you look at kranjar for £3 million and gundjohnson from barca went for £2 million i think these would have added something to or squad? cause there better then some of the squad mentioning no names.. cheers
baggins09 - September 5th, 2009 at 8:41 am
i would have likeed to have seen a loan for zaki with a view to buy with n’gog or voronin going the other way for a season, i think he would have complimented torres really well
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 9:47 am
Liverpool and via relation Benitez have no youth development programme geared towards giving, young players and products of the youth system a chance to prove themselves @ the top level. This is disappointing considering gems like Gerrard and Carragher have been developed @ Liverpool. And looking @ the way Arsenal and Manchester United have cultivated young players into stars and club icons. BENITEZ IS KILLING THE LIVERPOOL ACADEMY!
saif - September 5th, 2009 at 9:54 am
if he’s killing it then why has rafa bouth the best youngster scout in the world to the club the man who spoted world class players like messi favregas pique ect if that’s killing the youths or improving them and why are you looking at 4 matches in to the season to deside if rafa isn’t going to play youths
my prediction rafa to use a squad full of youtjs with torres and gerrard on the bench and the youths beat leeds
nanaghlfc - September 5th, 2009 at 9:56 am
warren u are right abt Pacheco he’ll certainly shine. Aquiliani is good player i’ve seen him play several times.
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 9:59 am
Liverpool need investment big time, if the yanks are selling other businesses they own with the intention of investing into LFC then great…. but I doubt it !!
Need new owners !!
January Dealings:
IN
Van Der Vaat £8m
Trezeguet £5m
Joe Cole £6m
Michael Johnson £3m
OUT
Voronin £5m
Babel £8m
Lucas £5m
Dossena £5m
Ngog £2m
Degen anything we can get !!
saif - September 5th, 2009 at 10:23 am
keep n’gog
january dealinIN
Van Der Vaat £5m + degen and one player on loan
Trezeguet £5m
Joe Cole £6m
Michael Johnson £3m
de feddrico £4m
a cople of free transfers
totel expenditure £23m
OUT
Voronin £5m
Babel £8m
Lucas £5m
Dossena £5m
Degen in deal for van der vaart
loan player in van der vaart deal
a few loans
totel income £23 mil
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 12:36 pm
we needed anohter striker, but glen johnson was a exellent buy for the club and we should of sold the likes of ryan babel and andrea dossena and lucas should have gone out on loan
anonymous - September 5th, 2009 at 4:36 pm
We shud sign usain volt.. T0res n volt up fr0nt!! All defenders will cry to chase them b0th!! Hahaha
saif - September 5th, 2009 at 4:44 pm
haha
how about we sign what i said in me previouse post