Ten Players Who Are Just Not Good Enough for Their Clubs
by Mr Neutral on September 8th, 2009 36 commentsThese players are not worthy of wearing the shirts of Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, Manchester United, Tottenham, West Ham, Hull, Aston Villa and Man City.
Phillip Degen (Liverpool)
Why this guy was ever purchased is a mystery as complex and pointless as The Da Vinci Code. Now that he has lurched from one injury to another his mere existence may well be in question and he may be the one Liverpool footballer who could walk past you in the street without being noticed.
Mikael Silvestre (Arsenal)
He may have used to be a decent player but believe me Arsenal fans wish that he never signed for the club. In theory it was a capture that seemed to make sense, an old head to help balance out the emergence of a youthful team but he is a flaming liability who merely makes his teammates have to work twice as hard to compensate for his sheet presence on the field.
Deco (Chelsea)
It’s not enough to occasionally do a nice trick on the ball or every now and then pull out a nice 30 yard pass. Deco is not half the player he used to be and last term he started with a bang and ended on a whimper, surely not a player Carlo Ancelotti will count on unless he really absolutely has no choice.
Gareth Bale (Tottenham)
Yes he is young and yes he has potential but it is not a compete coincidence that he has not played in a winning Premier League team. Will surely be offloaded as and when someone comes calling.
Javier Garrido (Manchester City)
Not the world’s worst player but not someone who is going to figure too highly on Mark Hughes starting eleven list this term. The Spaniard is an average player stuck at a club who is aiming far higher than Javier can ever hope to follow.
Marlon Harewood (Aston Villa)
Marlon can occasionally score a goal, I know I checked it on the internet he does score when given the chance but Martin O’Neill doesn’t feel like picking the former West Ham man and when a last ditch move to Hull City failed he was stuck at Villa Park but surely that will be rectified as soon as someone fancies paying actual money (monopoly money doesn’t count!). Managed just one goal in his last 24 appearances, that came against the great Litex of Bulgaria.
Paul McShane (Hull City)
Has anyone seen this guy play well in a game? Or even for a short period of time, lets say a minute, within one match? Seriously he is bad. Came through the Man United ranks until they realised he was not very good, luckily before he got a minute of senior football, and has then moved from club to club finding his way to Hull City who will surely find out soon enough that the Irishman has very questionable abilities as a professional footballer.
Luis Boa Morte (West Ham United)
Being injured is no excuse. The Portuguese winger has been pretty awful during his stuttering two and a half years at the club. Really is past it. A player who may have pace but can’t seem to control the ball when running with it. Gianfranco Zola would surely like to have his wage removed from the clubs outgoings.
Ryan Babel (Liverpool)
Into his third season at the club and seemingly no nearer to pleasing Rafa Benitez. No doubting his talent but the word potential can not so easily be used for a player who has had chance after chance to prove himself. Not good enough to represent Liverpool at this moment in time. It will take a big improvement to make up for the opportunities he has wasted.
Ben Foster (Man United)
When you are being lined up as a long term replacement for Edwin Van Der Sar then you need to be able to take a cross with ease and be able to kick the ball accurately or at least out of touch, you also need to take simple shots on target with ease, and Ben Foster at this moment in time can’t seem to do any of these things. Anyone who points out his great reflex save against Arsenal needs to look at the bigger picture, Foster just doesn’t cut the mustard right now and Sir Alex will surely look to find a safer pair of hands to hand the United gloves to.




anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 3:07 pm
Pretty fair list. I have to say I am hugely dissappointed with Mikael Silvestre whenever he has played for us he has looked a liability
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 3:08 pm
phillipe degen came on a bosman so we didnt buy him. thats why. he was good at hes old club except for injurys.
as for babel. he could be extremely good if he only changes hes attitude
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 3:20 pm
you are a fool if you want to ignore foster’s save from van Persie. he also made crucial saves from Benitez on the opening day, and at 0-0 against Wigan as well. nothing he could do about Blake’s screamer and was well beaten by Arshavin’s rocket as well. you don’t get much to do in goal at United most of the time, but Foster has played a key part in United gathering 9pts from 12, despite a few nerves.
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 3:30 pm
silvestre is awesome….but other than that i agree with the list..i think peter crouch should be on that list…
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 3:34 pm
Ben Foster is awesome, Mr.Neurtal is a fucking brainless ASSHOLE. Yes look at the bigger picture asshole.
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 3:35 pm
I don’t think Paul McShane deserves to be there? I saw him a few times when he was on loan to Hull at the start of last season and he looked fairly decent, he’s strong in the tackle, has good positional sense and his distribution is ok. He may not get forward and add support to the attack like Sam Ricketts used to but he’s certainly not a bad player!
Retryboy - September 8th, 2009 at 3:43 pm
Degen for sure still a total waste of wages we had better right backs when he arrived and even more so now with glen johnson here and stephen darby another season older think babel will come good if he gets a run up front he is fast and got a hell of a strike whether its at liverpool or not remains 2 be seen lucas should be number 1 on your list by a mile apart from ben foster who is a quality keeper even tho he does play for the scum rest of the list is pretty fair could add reo-coker, bendtner carrick and actually just stick the whole united team in there
isaac hunt - September 8th, 2009 at 3:45 pm
well the only decent game paul mcshane had was against liverpool last year! foster is not world class or anwhere near it. he makes good saves but he isnt anywhere near as consistant as vds. deco looks like he might start playing like how he use to.
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 4:16 pm
instead of babel it should be that arsehole lucas he is a shit head
isaac hunt - September 8th, 2009 at 4:20 pm
yep. i would rather have babel than lucas anyday of the week. then again i would rather have dean windass than him!!
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 4:39 pm
watttt no mention of LUCAS LEVIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
he is a total waste of time!!
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 4:41 pm
hull city have made a gr8 buy out of mcshane at least when we had him we were winning more than when he left and rickett came in so you are wrong!!!!
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 4:45 pm
lucas should definitely be on there, and michael owen …
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 4:46 pm
never mind lucas wat about VORONIN
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 5:17 pm
dont forget ngog,elzahr,lucas,degen,voronin,babel,aurelio thats 7 from liverpool all those players are a total WASTE OF SPACE! rafa is also useless who doesnt have a single clue on how to produce a winning PL team the sooner he goes the better LFC will be what manager ships out nemeth on loan and sticks with fat useless long haired turds in voronin,and ngog,elzahr & babel all are UTTER,UTTER SHIT RAFA JUST GO NOW B4 U DO MORE DAMAGE!!!!!!!
Id also put FAT BOY SHREK ROONEY on the list as he is the most overrated player ever the FAT FCUKER cant run the UGLY TWAT!
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 5:38 pm
Where is Michael Owen and David James? Foster don’t deserve this, he is playing just fine at this point and disregarding a GREAT save to prove your point (not worth supporting) is amateurish.
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 7:11 pm
I’m a lfc fan and i would love to have rooney in our side even if he is a blue nose. Rafa is a genius.
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 7:14 pm
ur all mad. babel has had limited game time. same as foster (only 1 full season at watford i fink). Lucas has consistently improved. Suggestions for Owen…are u fuckin kidding me? have you seen his goal record? Silvestre (the spy) & Harewood i agree with! Degen, again has had no game time but from what i’ve seen previously he aint all that and a bag of potato chips. Some poor suggestions from author & comments.To put deco in as not good enough for the club & leave out mikkel, bosingwa & the rest is pretty astonishing. I’d personally put Robbie Keane, honestly what has he done!? i also hate all this praise vidic gets…did any1 see the lpool v utd games? any sign of pace & he lost it. worst player in the premier league anyone?…..
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 7:15 pm
ps 2nd that- rafa is a genius!
Jeduardo - September 8th, 2009 at 7:17 pm
i dont see how u can include silvestre and foster on the list
Jed - September 8th, 2009 at 8:25 pm
every player on this list would be a first teamer at liverpool
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 9:40 pm
Jed you chelski rent boy why dont you do one with your so intelligent comments you are a p****
anonymous - September 8th, 2009 at 9:55 pm
I Agree with the Robbie keane comments i thought he was woefull at liverpool he is definately not a top four player and i personally wanted him to do well at Anfield along with many others, but maybe the price tag got the better of him, i dont know. If liverpool had paid about 6mil for him, i think he would still be at anfield as a sqad player. As for Babel he has so much potential but it is his mentality and passion that lets him down ‘lazy’ i also think Lucas has come on his mental strengh needs to be congratulated. what we have to rememember is that he is young he has come to a different culture enviroment, football style etc how many of us go andwork in a different country and fit in straight away ?
Retryboy - September 9th, 2009 at 12:17 am
Out of those 7 for liverpool only babel cost any real money aurelio, el zhar and babel are good squad players but agree with all the points about voronin being in and nemeth loaned out crazy and lucas ‘liability’ leiva what has he improved every1 his heading ability against villa? How to go through a whole game without contributing one thing?
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 4:05 am
Rafa is a genius. Are you kidding me. The guy is a liability.
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 5:46 am
were is Robinho ont this list? he is ridiculous!!!!
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 12:14 pm
Errrr. Degen was a free, we didnt ‘purchase’ him.
Also There are far worse players at LFC than Babel. So you singling him out if ridiculous. Hes better than Lucas, and Voronin (Who we also didnt pruchase)
Hes better than el zhar, ngog… bla bla bla
Dom - September 9th, 2009 at 12:15 pm
Errrr. Degen was a free, we didnt ‘purchase’ him.
Also There are far worse players at LFC than Babel. So you singling him out if ridiculous. Hes better than Lucas, and Voronin (Who we also didnt pruchase)
Hes better than el zhar, ngog… bla bla bla
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 12:28 pm
Jed suck’s fat lampards cock for his lunch money on Saturday , heard it’s Drogba’s turn on monday . Not sure abouth the rest of the week ? Post your guesses here guy’s , cause everybody love’s Jed
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 3:29 pm
No Lucas?
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 3:32 pm
harewood could get in a liverpool team
cos he is defo better than torres
also mcshane sivestre garrido and bale, would have no chance against the likes of glenson, skrtel, agger and aurelio (liverpools best back 4)
also reina probably best goaly in prem so how would foster get in
jed your a moron
anonymous - September 9th, 2009 at 5:49 pm
I was annoyed with Foster in preseason but since then he’s come good. He just needs the experience and playing first team football is how he’s going to get it.
RyanO - September 10th, 2009 at 12:40 am
I’ve got to disagree with the anonymous muppet blasting the choice of Michael Owen for this team. We are more than aware of his goal record, we are also more than aware how many records The Beatles have sold. Both of these are in the past. Owen wasn’t good enough for a Newcastle shirt AFTER they were relegated. There is NO WAY he is good enough for the United shirt and that is coming from a Manc hater.
anonymous - September 14th, 2009 at 8:35 pm
you are very stupid to say such crap about deco.he is not as young as he used to be but he will always be able to perform
anonymous - September 20th, 2009 at 1:04 am
you are retard mate,
anonymous - September 24th, 2009 at 4:22 pm
bendtner is the worst player attacker in the world god help arsenal & the danish national side the most awkward player i’ve seen in my life i used to think peter crouch is awkward but atleast he scores alot
i don’t approve of this list as long as there is no bendtner involved
a defender who makes a mistake is put under the monitor right away
but an attacker can miss as much as he wants just as long as he scores
in the end but bendtner doesn’t do that
this guy should be cleaning shoes at subways!!