Liverpool 2-2 Birmingham Premier League Player Ratings and Analysis
by YNWA on November 10th, 2009 18 commentsConfidence and luck running low at Anfield.
Portsmouth Vs Liverpool Tickets Still Available!
Join Our Facebook Fan Page for the Latest News/Rumours/Forums/Videos/WAGS/Funny Stuff/Features!

27 shots to 5. That’s the real story of last night’s match. It seems that whereas previously we were not performing and rightfully coming out of games with nothing we are now not getting the rub of the green.
But for late goals in both matches against Lyon we would have seven points and not four from our Champions League encounters and now we find ourselves having to deal with yet another set of dropped points, this time at home to Birmingham.
Rafa Benitez is obviously struggling to make do with the players available to him after injuries and suspensions decimated our squad and the line up he sent out should still have been able to overcome Alex McLeish’s side. In the first half we got the early goal we so dearly need these days to settle confidence but too many players were not firing on all cylinders.
Albert Riera was as greedy as ever. The Spaniard always takes too long to move on possession choosing to either take another touch or more often than not going it alone and failing to achieve anything other than picking out a fan in row Z with his flailing shots. I am afraid my patience for the winger has run out and I just don’t see him being of sufficient quality to play for us.
Our centre backs once again switched off from a set piece and failed to deal with a fairly standard ball into the box, failing to deal with the initial delivery and then not being able to stop Cristian Benitez from scoring from two yards out. It seems that whatever pairing we pick to put in front of Pepe, they consistently fail to deal with the most basic aspects of the game.
One member of the back four who does come out of the game with nothing but plaudits is Glen Johnson. He was awesome, a constant menace down the right, so often the instigator of our waves of attack the England man is a cut above and in my view the best right back in the country right now.
David Ngog took his goal well and was also a positive to take from this match. There was nothing much that could be done about Cameron Jerome’s long range strike, yes Reina was off his line but I don’t think we can blame him for not being able to stop that thunderbolt, the former Cardiff man really hit it in the sweet spot.
The second half was all us and Riera’s injury, and he would surely have been subbed at half time anyway, meant we got to see Stevie G earlier than the boss would have brought him on. More than likely our gaffer would have waited until the hour mark to bring him on so thankfully he was forced into making a decision we would all have liked to have seen much earlier.
Lucas was pretty solid as was Javier Mascherano and it really was down to our back four’s inability to get rid of the ball and defend in a confident manner that cost us all three points.
Now we come to THAT penalty. I’m afraid that even though we don’t want to admit it, we have to say it as we saw it, regardless of whether it’s by a member of our own squad. David Ngog took a horrible dive the kind that really should have gotten him booked. Lee Carsley made no contact whatsoever and only a sub standard ref, and that is what Peter Walton is, would have fallen for it. Gerrard put away the spot kick perfectly and we then had twenty minutes to get the winner but try as we might we just couldn’t manage it.
I think the introductions of both Ryan Babel and Alberto Aquilani would have been best made just after that penalty and not when they did. We needed to exert pressure on our opponents at that point and I do think that Rafa once again dawdled too long and didn’t give either sub enough time to get themselves into the game.
So it’s a point that keeps us in seventh place which is a hideous position to be in and we really have done ourselves no favours in the top four race. The boss can blame injuries all he wants but we shouldn’t be so dependent on Gerrard and Torres in the first place so anytime Rafa claims that the absence of either party is to blame it just serves to show how ineffectively he has handled additions to the squad.
Reina 6 – Didn’t have much to do and perhaps should have been on his line for the second
Johnson 9 – Man of the Match without doubt. Fantastic attacking play
Agger 5 – Tried to come forward more in the second half but was not good at all
Insua 6 – Average game from the Argentine
Skrtel 5 – Clumsy and unable to deal with the basic aspects of defending
Riera 4 – Truly horrid performance. Greedy, lazy and slowed down every first half attack
(Gerrard) 7 – Good touches and took his penalty well
Benayoun 7 – A little subdued but as always looked like he would spark life into the team
(Babel) 6 – A couple of bad touches but not enough time to impose himself on the game
Mascherano 7 – Good game
Lucas 7.5 – Continues to grow as a player. Good distribution
(Aquilani) 6 – Didn’t have enough time to get into the game
Kuyt 7 – Dogged running, full of determination as always
Ngog 7.5 – Took his goal well and made other chances as well
YNWA
Related Posts:
Revealed: Liverpool Boss Job Application Form




anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 11:45 am
Was actually at the game and from that point of view:
Reina: 7 (didn’t have to make many saves, and was a bit slow at getting the ball upfield when we needed it. Shouldn’t have been so far off his line for their second, but can’t deny the finish!).
Agger: 7 (Didn’t win a single header from the kop point of view. But made some great tackles throughout the game)
Insua: 4 (Too many bad passes, crosses were poor and was too slow at the back)
Skrtel: 8 (Really gave it his all. He was first to everything and really pushed forward when possible)
Johnson: 9 (Once again he proves he is a world class right back. Great attacking play and defended like a machine! So skilful when he wants to be)
Lucas: 7 (Great game all-round. Good passing, great tackling and positive play)
Benayoun: 7 (Not one of his best games but did what he does every game. Opens up play and doesn’t release the ball for the sake of it)
Riera: 5 (Too many mistakes and poor shots. Pulled off a few nice moves coming in field to make some good crosses, but nothing that really fuelled the game. Good cross to the back post for Ngog to score, but that could have gone anywhere)
Mascherano: 8 (GREAT pressure on their midfield and attack, some really fantastic tackles and opened up the wide play. Sometimes he was a bit hesitant to get it wide, but overall he was great)
Ngog: 9 (For someone that has had so much criticism over the last few months, he really did his part last night. He’s got a great ability to score, and with time can really become something great. When he’s on the ball he reminds me of crouhc, a little googly and unsure what to do at times, but overall can score goals!)
Kuyt: 7 (Did alright, but wasn’t his best game. Had a couple of poor shots but overall a typical Kuyt performance!)
Gerrard: 9 (His passing was immense, his crossing just blew everyone else’s out the water. Great penalty and such a lifeline to our team)
Aquilani: N/A (Not much to see but promising stuff from his passing and eye for the game. Not going to give a rating until I see more)
Babel: 6 (Shown some really great skill and speed at times, but still insists on running past players without the ball, and infield. Needs to stick where he’s played and keep wide!)
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 1:10 pm
Liverpool were extremely unlucky last night. Camerom Jerome’s goal was brilliant but is a one off. Yes they got a lucky penalty and it was an appaling dive but a draw was the least they deserved. Its just a shame that after they scored the equaliser they didnt have too many chances.
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 1:14 pm
Great analysis anon above. It’s a shame that N’Gog is getting stick for the penalty (dive) as he did have a good game and as you say, with time he can become something great.. It’s a shame that we let in another goal from a set piece as , great goal aside, Birmingham offered nothing and as the game wore on there was only one team in it. A draw is a fair result considering the amount of play that Liverpool had and the fact that the pen was a bit controvesial.
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 1:19 pm
Cheers.
We contraversial penalty was justice as we deserved all 3 points in my opinion. We dominated them throughout the match. Their second goal was definitely one for goal of the season, and it’s something that can happen to any keeper at anytime.
We were unlucky not to take all 3 points, but we do need to take our chances better if we ever stand a chance of competing for the title again.
Retryboy - November 10th, 2009 at 1:37 pm
Reality check-This is birmingham we were playing! it shouldn’t have taken gerrard to push the tempo we should have been bombarding them from the start. Not prod and probe with 2 defensive midfielders we let them into the game. We gave them something to defend. Benayoun should have been in the hole not kuyt. Too many workhorses not enough players capable of that bit of magic in the attacking areas. Disgusting we have to cheat to get a draw against birmingham. Ruined a good performance by ngog. Aquilani should have been involved much earlier
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 2:16 pm
I thinks ESPN’s court room drama after the game was totally un necessary. Since when did we allow players the right to voice there objections after the game and for the character assassination Carlsey gave was totally unfair. While I don’t agree with the diving, it still happens, and Ngog was more within his right to go down as easy as the drogba’s and eduardo’s, especially the Carsley flew in. Ngog had a good game and hopfully gets more time now Vronin’s gone AWOL
kermit - November 10th, 2009 at 3:18 pm
ratings for last night,
reina 6, too far off his line for the second, but unstoppable shot really , i would have given him a sevn if he were three inches taller
johnson 9 brilliant attacking play from the full back
skrtel 6 amazingly neither centre backs had much to do but he was outjumped for the first goal
agger 7 see skrtel but with more invention going forward
insua 6 was he playing
kuyt 4 poor performance from dirk, inabilty to cross the ball
lucas 7 played reasonably well
mascherano 6 , dont see how you can give him an eight
benayoun 6.5 okay but nothing spectacular
riera 7 looked bright but a little too greedy on his return
ngog 8 well done david, great run to create the penalty and well taken first goal
subs gerrard 7 showed touches of class
babel 6.5 showed a little of his running with the ball skills but didnt have enough time to get involved in the game
aquilani not applicable
rafa benitez 4/10 WHAT A MORON
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 3:21 pm
Fucking hell. At least N’Gog didn’t write about like he was having a seizure NOT MENTIONING ANY WORLD CLASS STRIKER NAMES.
I thought Babel did well when he came on, to be honest. And the more I see Johnson shooting forward, the more I think we should play him right wing. He’s like Messi when he gets going!
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 3:22 pm
for those of you blaming the centre backs for set pieces, you do realise that its majority of the players in our team that also help defend them – but we have too many short players i.e. benny, lucas, masch, kuyt, insua – im not saying they are crap but we could do with a few tall players, but we need better wingers asap
Ryan Babel - November 10th, 2009 at 3:49 pm
Do you not think if N’gog built up he could be like drogba. casuse N’gog is 1.88m and drogba’s 1.89m tall
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 4:36 pm
If Rafa was smart at the beginning of the EPL he would play N’gog and not the stupid Lucas. Than we would had a 4-4-2 formation and won’t be in the position like we are now.
Warren Bloggs - November 10th, 2009 at 5:20 pm
Lucas has been the best performer in a liverpool shirt so far this season with the exception of Benny. He improves as each game goes by and i can see him being a big player for us in the future.
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 6:06 pm
Kop King
Dirk kuyt is the most over rated player in the premiership i am sure if he were not playing then we would be at least 5 to 6 points better off, we need a natural right winger with pace as all the best teams have blistering pace in their attacking line ups.
Retryboy - November 10th, 2009 at 6:09 pm
Lucas is massively improved don’t like the balance of the side with him, mascherano and kuyt in though in my eyes you only need one workhorse sitting in front of the back four and thats mascherano. Lucas is now an able deputy and a valuable squad member. He’s getting into good positions more often now though if he could weigh in with the odd goal and add killer through balls to his repertoire would be a top player and he is looking forward a lot more when passing now.
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 6:09 pm
again the ridicoulous .5 on the end of certain player ratings,it’s not impossible to mark out of ten,wihout having to add another 10 possible rating’s
anonymous - November 10th, 2009 at 6:34 pm
riera played fantastic y put him as 4 u might as well put johnson as 3 and y not put gerard as 1
Donavan Ried - November 10th, 2009 at 7:27 pm
Match rating time again uhh!
anonymous - November 11th, 2009 at 12:37 pm
liverpool should lost the match