Ranking The 20 Premier League Captains in Order of How Good They are as Players

How the skippers from the English top tier rate.

The list of Premier League captains is an odd list and here at CaughOffside we have decided to rank the 20 in order of how good they are as players.

20. Robert Koren – Hull City

Someone had to be last and unfortunately for looking out of depth at the top it’s Koren.

19. Lee Cattermole – Sunderland

May seem a little harsh on the midfielder as there is a good player in there somewhere – it’s just staying on the pitch long enough to show it that is the issue.

18. Ryan Shawcross – Stoke City

For some bizarre reason for a short time the Potteries skipper was linked with an England cap, which luckily never materialised.

17. Michael Dawson – Tottenham Hotspur

Short of pace and clearly out of the centre-back’s depth and is very lucky to still be playing for a top flight team at all.

16. Ashley Williams – Swansea City

Perhaps one of the most overrated players in the entire division, with a defensive tactic of getting beaten and then putting in a last ditch tackle.

15. Ron Vlaar – Aston Villa

It’s starting to edge towards the more respectable end of talent, although admittedly very slowly, as this injury prone Dutchman is hardly a defender to rely on in a crisis.

14. Chris Brunt – West Bromwich Albion

Can take a decent free-kick and corner but apart from that it’s plain old average for the Scot.

13. Mile Jedinak – Crystal Palace

Has had a good season for the Eagles in what has been a difficult campaign, although whether that is simply being the best of a bad bunch is unknown.

12. Brede Hangeland – Fulham

Was once a highly sought after centre-back – but then again so was Chris Samba – and the Norway international looks a shadow of the defensive behemoth of old.

11. Kevin Nolan – West Ham United

Another who could have been argued to have talent (well Nolan could be relied upon to pop up with a goal in any case), but those days are largely gone for the midfielder.

10. Sebastien Bassong – Norwich City

There may be some raised eyebrows that Bassong has made the top 10, but when looking at the rest of the list it becomes apparent.

9. Steven Caulker – Cardiff City

The Bluebirds are hardly famed for a brilliant defence, but this 22-year-old is someone who shows genuine promise – although that happens a lot with Englishmen.

8. Thomas Vermaelen – Arsenal

Having barely played all year many will probably be calling for the Belgian to be lower down the list, but Vermaelen could cut it at a mid-table side.

7. Fabricio Coloccini – Newcastle United

Has been one of the Magpies better players in the past few years, although having cost £10m from Deportivo La Coruna back in the day the north east side should hope so.

6. Adam Lallana – Southampton

Finally, some genuine top-class talent on the list as this attacking midfielder is enjoying a great campaign and is now an England international.

5. Phil Jageilka – Everton

The defender and former side Sheffield United’s fortunes couldn’t be more different; Jagielka has enjoyed a brilliant career at Goodison Park and is a regular for the Three Lions, the Blades are about to be relegated to League Two.

4. Nemanja Vidic – Manchester United

Once a defensive powerhouse the Serbian is still a good player, but is far from the terrifying force that dominated the English top tier a few years ago.

3. John Terry – Chelsea

Up until the return of Jose Mourinho the 33-year-old may not have made it this high, but the Portuguese coach has inspired Terry to find the form of old.

2. Steven Gerrard – Liverpool

One of the most consistent performers the league has ever seen and now in the twilight years of the midfielder’s career, is still as good as ever.

1. Vincent Kompany – Manchester City

The one genuinely world-class star on the list – although that could have been argued for Gerrard, Terry and Vidic in the past – the Belgium international is simply brilliant.

Find out the top ten Ashes moments from England and Australia’s cricket rivalry here in this great piece from fanatix!

Find out the top 10 biggest match-fixing scandals in sport history.