Anthony Martial – Manchester United
HIT
Eyebrows were raised when United spent the £36m striker budget on the teenager on transfer deadline day, but he has so far proved to be worth every penny. With seven goals in 12 games across all competitions, he is outshining star striker Wayne Rooney at every turn.
Roberto Firmino – Liverpool
MISS
Injuries have prevented the Brazilian international from showing the Anfield faithful what he can do since his summer arrival, but in truth he still looks as though he is finding his feet in the division and has yet to gain any real match sharpness.