Tottenham player ratings from 4-1 Monaco win: Lamela MOTM, 8/10 N’Jie & Carroll also shine for Spurs

Posted by

Erik Lamela scored a first-half hat-trick to send Tottenham Hotspur into the Europa League knockout stages as Group J winners courtesy of their 4-1 victory over Monaco at White Hart Lane.

The Argentine’s first career treble sent him onto five goals in the competition this season, and Tom Carroll added a fourth for Spurs in the second half after Stephan El Shaarawy’s consolation.

SEE MORE: Tottenham 4-1 Monaco report & video: Lamela inspires impressive Europa League win

Here, CaughtOffside rates how Mauricio Pochettino’s side performed in North London…

GK: Hugo Lloris – 6/10

Could not do much about Monaco’s goal after it took a deflection off Wimmer, but needs to organise his defence better from set pieces as Tottenham often looked vulnerable.

RB: Kieran Trippier – 6/10

The former Burnley full-back has started all of Tottenham’s six Europa League group games this season. Solid in general although beaten quite easily for Monaco’s reply.

CB: Toby Alderweireld – 7/10

Pochettino made seven changes from the team which drew 1-1 with West Bromwich Albion on Saturday, but the Belgian is indispensable and put in another assured display.

CB: Kevin Wimmer – 7/10

The Austrian took advantage of a rare chance to show Pochettino that he would be able to fill in if either one of his first-choice centre-backs get injured. Strong and composed.

LB: Ben Davies – 7/10

Picked out Lamela for Tottenham’s second-minute opener with a precise cutback. Minimised Monaco’s threat down the left-hand side but was outjumped from a few corners.

CM: Eric Dier – 6/10

Picked up a knock in the first half. Did not want to come off but Pochettino was understandably cautious with one of his star players and substituted him before the break.

CM: Tom Carroll – 8/10

Tottenham’s academy graduate capped off an impressive performance with a very stylish first goal for the club. Deserves more game time but may find it hard to come by in this midfield.

AMR: Erik Lamela – 9/10

Unsurprisingly, Tottenham’s hat-trick hero was the star of the show. Took goals one and three particularly well and was given a standing ovation when he came off on 62 minutes.

SEE MORE: Erik Lamela hat-trick v Monaco: Rare right-footer seals Argentine’s first Spurs treble

AMC: Clinton N’Jie – 8/10

The summer signing’s work rate was outstanding. On countless times he pinched the ball in the Monaco half and launched Tottenham attacks. Had a couple of chances to add a goal to a fine display.

AML: Joshua Onomah – 7/10

Pochettino awarded the teenager with a full debut and he did not look out of place. The 18-year-old is confident, strong and quick and slotted into this Tottenham side with ease.

ST: Son Heung-Min – 6/10

Too often Son was selfish in attack and went for goal himself rather than look for a teammate, although he did tee up Lamela for his hat-trick goal. Is trying to impress, but perhaps too much.


Nabil Bentaleb – 6/10

The Algerian, who last played for Spurs in August, got a valuable hour under his belt. Oozes confidence and class but took unnecessary risks in his own half too often.

Nacer Chadli – 5/10

Made his return from a two-month layoff but had little impact in his 30-minute cameo. Will find it hard to regain his place considering the form of Lamela.

Dele Alli – 6/10

The teenage prodigy got the last 12 minutes and immediately involved himself in the play. Sent Son through with a delightful slide-rule pass which the Korean could have made more of.

Jeff Stelling racism row: Sky presenter offends viewers with politically incorrect Japan joke
Gary Neville’s Sky Sports replacement: Liverpool failure & BBC playboy among top five candidates
Video: John Terry’s ‘young wife’ asked for ID at Winter Wonderland

More Stories Ben Davies Clinton N’Jie Dele Alli Eric Dier Erik Lamela Hugo Lloris Joshua Onomah Kevin Wimmer Kieran Trippier Nabil Bentaleb Nacer Chadli Son Heung-min Toby Alderweireld Tom Carroll