Man United player ratings v Man City: 8/10 trio back-up Marcus Rashford in Red Devils’ derby victory

Posted by

Manchester United clinched a massive derby victory which could reignite their season as a solitary Marcus Rashford goal knocked off Manchester City at the Etihad Stadium.

The Red Devils put in a vibrant attacking display in the first half, and then produced a strong rearguard action after the break to inflict a fifth home defeat of the season on City.

Louis van Gaal’s side are now within one point of their local rivals in the race for the final Champions League spot, and can put the Europa League exit to Liverpool behind them.

Here, CaughtOffside rates how United performed on derby day at Eastlands…

Marcus Rashford goal video v Man City: Teenage striker burns Martin Demichelis for derby delight
Manchester United could trigger £19.5m release clause of one of Gary Neville’s Valencia stars
Jose Mourinho to make £60m Harry Kane transfer priority once he takes over at Manchester United

GK: David de Gea – 6/10

So often United’s standout player, the Spaniard took a backseat today. Did not have many saves to make by virtue of the defence in front of him, and City’s wayward finishing.

RB: Matteo Darmian – 6/10

Started pretty solidly, limiting himself in an attacking sense to focus on protecting his flank. Was switched to left-back in the second half and was then exposed slightly.

CB: Chris Smalling – 8/10

Did not have everything his own way against Sergio Aguero in the first half, but led an outstanding United defensive effort in the second half. Lucky not to be sent off, though.

Chris Smalling Man United v Man City

CB: Daley Blind – 7/10

Did his part alongside Smalling. There has been much criticism of United’s recent transfer record, but Blind, capable in several positions, is undoubtedly a success story.

LB: Marcos Rojo – 5/10

Substituted on 63 minutes after a poor game. Made a few sloppy mistakes and was given a difficult time by Jesus Navas, who did not make the most of United’s weak link.

CM: Morgan Schneiderlin – 7/10

Got among City’s midfield to help United initially boss the centre of the park, and showed more confidence on the ball than he has for much of his time at Old Trafford.

CM: Michael Carrick – 8/10

Remains such a key player for United. Released the ball forward quickly to maximise the attacking threat, and made a couple of crucial defensive interventions to deny City probable goals.

Michael Carrick

AMR: Juan Mata – 7/10

Will collect an assist for Rashford’s goal, although the teenager did much of the work himself! Most of Mata’s good work today was from a work-rate and defensive perspective.

AMC: Jesse Lingard – 7/10

Eyebrows have been raised by Van Gaal’s decision to move Lingard into a central role of late, but the youngster helped expose City’s lack of pace with his intelligent movement.

AML: Anthony Martial – 8/10

Another excellent showing from the Frenchman, who took the game to City’s defence from the first whistle to last. Very difficult to stop when dribbling at defenders off the left.

ST: Marcus Rashford – 9/10

There is more than the fearlessness of youth to this 18-year-old. He can really play. Showed great speed and technique to score and should also have had a penalty. Man of the match.

Marcus Rashford Manchester United v Man City


Antonio Valencia – 6/10

Made his first Premier League appearance since October, off the bench for Darmian. Slotted in at right-back for half an hour in which most of City’s threat emanated from the opposite wing.

Bastian Schweinsteiger – 6/10

Replaced Juan Mata on 70 minutes to solidify United’s midfield. The veteran German barely got on the ball, but ensured that the Citizens had to go wide to try to find an equalising goal.

Timothy Fosu-Mensah – 5/10

The youngster ended up playing 15 minutes because of the healthy portion of injury time. Allowed Aguero to bring down a cross at the far post, but luckily the Argentine fired wide.

Luke Shaw injury: Roy Hodgson leaves Euro 2016 door open for Manchester United crock
Jose Mourinho Man United: Special One signs pre-contract agreement to take Old Trafford job
sign pre-contract agreement; financial commitment made to ex-Chelsea coach

More Stories Anthony Martial Antonio Valencia Bastian Schweinsteiger Chris Smalling daley blind David de Gea Jesse Lingard Juan Mata Marcos Rojo Marcus Rashford Matteo Darmian Michael Carrick morgan schneiderlin Timothy Fosu Mensah