Menu

Premier League’s 20 dirtiest players over last five years: Man United thug top, Arsenal squeaky clean

We all know who has been the best Premier League player over the past five years – Marcus Rashford, obviously – but who has been the dirtiest?

The Telegraph has calculated the 20 biggest thugs using a formula which attributes a point each for a foul, three for a yellow card, and six for a red.

Arsenal are the only team to have been in the top flight for all of the time period not to have a player on this list. That’s where the Gunners are going wrong!

SEE MORE: Arsenal star headed for exit, replacement already lined up

20. Ryan Shawcross (Stoke City)
Games: 156
Disciplinary points: 244

The Potters captain takes no prisoners, and the fans love him for it!

19. Yaya Toure (Manchester City)
Games: 154
Disciplinary points: 245

He is particularly angry when people forget that it is his birthday.

18. Ashley Williams (Swansea City)
Games: 176
Disciplinary points: 248

Swansea’s leader makes the list but has never been sent off in the Premier League.

17. Pablo Zabaleta (Manchester City)
Games: 122
Disciplinary points: 261

The Argentine full-back loves a good tackle, but occasionally gets it wrong.

David Luiz + Pablo Zabaleta + Rafael Benitez Chelsea Manchester City

16. Claudio Yacob (West Bromwich Albion)
Games: 104
Disciplinary points: 261

West Brom’s midfield enforcer is the perfect Tony Pulis player – filthy!

15. Sebastian Larsson (Sunderland)
Games: 149
Disciplinary points: 263

The midfielder is more of a savage Swede than a set-piece specialist these days.

14. Mousa Dembele (Fulham & Tottenham Hotspur)
Games: 146
Disciplinary points: 263

Dembele never fouls. It is just that he is twice as strong as everybody else.

13. Gabriel Agbonlahor (Aston Villa)
Games: 140
Disciplinary points: 265

Villa could have done with Agbonlahor directing his aggression towards goal this season.

12. Lucas Leiva (Liverpool)
Games: 105
Disciplinary points: 273

Lucas actually has a higher disciplinary points per-game ratio than all but three players on this list.

Lucas Leiva Liverpool

11. Branislav Ivanovic (Chelsea)
Games: 163
Disciplinary points: 274

Ivanovic does not have a poor disciplinary record, but he has played a lot of games.

10. Ramires (Chelsea)
Games: 130
Disciplinary points: 276

We knew there was a reason that a Chinese Premier League club would pay £25m for him!

9. James McCarthy (Wigan Athletic & Everton)
Games: 154
Disciplinary points: 282

McCarthy is an all-action midfielder so it is hardly a surprise to see him make the top 10.

8. Morgan Schneiderlin (Southampton & Manchester United)
Games: 118
Disciplinary points: 289

Only been booked five times for United this season. Come on Morgan, stick your foot in!

7. Lee Cattermole (Sunderland)
Games: 109
Disciplinary points: 302

Admit it, you expected him to be higher! Cattermole would be third if it was on a per-game basis.

Lee Cattermole

6. Craig Gardner (Sunderland & West Bromwich Albion)
Games: 142
Disciplinary points: 303

Sunderland again? The training sessions at the Academy of Light must be like a war zone.

5. Jack Colback (Sunderland & Newcastle United)
Games: 161
Disciplinary points: 303

Substituted in Sunday’s Tyne-Wear derby when he looked like a red card waiting to happen.

4. Charlie Adam (Liverpool & Stoke City)
Games: 132
Disciplinary points: 304

The Scottish pass-master has a proper naughty streak in him. Just ask Gareth Bale.

3. Cheick Tiote (Newcastle United)
Games: 105
Disciplinary points: 341

The only player to average more than three disciplinary points per game in the Telegraph’s table.

2. Gareth Barry (Manchester City & Everton)
Games: 158
Disciplinary points: 367

The Premier League’s most yellow carded player ever is only just kept off top spot.

paul mcshane hull city marouane fellaini manchester united

1. Marouane Fellaini (Everton & Manchester United)
Games: 126
Disciplinary points: 371

So it is settled then, Fellaini is definitely a thug. United’s Belgian battering ram is the dirtiest player in the Premier League over the last five years with 296 fouls conceded, 23 yellow card and one red.

SEE ALSO:
Ex-referee brands Manchester United star a thug after latest controversy
Chelsea or Manchester United can have Mauricio Pochettino for £10m
Arsenal should pay over the odds in order to land £33.7m midfielder who would be perfect for Gunners

More Stories Ashley Williams Branislav Ivanovic Charlie Adam cheick tiote Claudio Yacob craig gardner gabriel agbonlahor Gareth Barry Jack Colback James McCarthy lee cattermole Lucas Leiva Marouane Fellaini morgan schneiderlin Mousa Dembele pablo zabaleta Ramires Ryan Shawcross Sebastian Larsson Yaya Toure