Manchester United player ratings vs Arsenal: Herrera and Mata in top form but strikers flop

Manchester United thought they had done enough to seal all three points against Arsenal on Saturday but were held to a 1-1 draw by their rivals.

Juan Mata gave the home side the lead, but Olivier Giroud struck late on to ensure that the two sides had to settle for a point apiece.

In turn, Jose Mourinho would have been disappointed as his side missed the chance to close the gap on the top four.

Manchester United player ratings:

David De Gea – 6

Had little to do throughout the game and was unable to do much about Giroud’s header finding the back of the net.

Antonio Valencia – 7

Wasn’t asked to do much defensively and so had the freedom to break forward and cause Arsenal problems. A welcome return to action after injury.

Phil Jones – 5

Slipped in the build-up to Giroud’s goal which ruined what was otherwise a decent performance as he looks to put together a run of games.

Marcos Rojo – 6

The Argentine wasn’t afraid to get stuck into a tackle and produced a solid display to give Mourinho a reason to keep him in the team.

Matteo Darmian – 5

Risked being sent off in the first half and was replaced early as he didn’t do much to silence speculation over a possible exit in January.

Michael Carrick – 7

Despite his advancing years, he continues to play a pivotal role for United in front of the defence as he keeps things ticking for his side.

Ander Herrera – 8

Tenacious display from the Spaniard as he wasn’t afraid to put his foot in while also getting on the ball and pushing the tempo of the game.

Juan Mata – 8

Took his goal very well with a clinical finish and continues to play a decisive role for United as a creative spark for his side behind the striker.

Paul Pogba – 6

Some flashes of how commanding and classy he can be but wasn’t consistent enough to dominate the game for his side in midfield.

Anthony Martial – 5

Had a couple of moments that looked threatening but wasn’t clinical and was eventually replaced as he was too quiet in general.

Marcus Rashford – 6

Still not reaching the heady heights of last season even in his preferred role up front but worked hard for his teammates off the ball.


Wayne Rooney – 5

Despite his troubles last week, was given 30 minutes but wasn’t able to offer a decisive contribution.

Daley Blind – 5

The Dutchman was brought on to help control the game and see out the win but things didn’t stick to the plan.

Morgan Schneiderlin – 5

Similar to Blind in that he was brought on to protect United’s lead but United conceded late on to drop points.

More Stories Ander Herrera Anthony Martial Antonio Valencia David de Gea Juan Mata Marcos Rojo Marcus Rashford Matteo Darmian Michael Carrick Paul Pogba Phil Jones