Erik Ten Hag made key transfer decision after deciding midfielder wasn’t good enough

Posted by
Manchester United's English midfielder James Garner (L) vies with Rayo Vallecano's Argentinian midfielder Oscar Trejo (R) during a pre-season club friendly football match between Manchester United and Rayo Vallecano at Old Trafford in Manchester, north west England, on July 31, 2022. (Photo by Nigel Roddis / AFP) (Photo by NIGEL RODDIS/AFP via Getty Images)

Despite enjoying a hugely successful season while out on loan with Nottingham Forest last season, Manchester United allowed midfielder James Garner to join Everton on a permanent deal during this summer’s transfer window.

The decision, which angered some fans, came as a surprise, especially considering how impressive the 21-year-old had been in the Championship last time out.

Having featured in 69 matches for Steve Copper’s Forest, across all competitions, Garner, who also has four under-21 England caps under his belt, directly contributed to a decent 18 goals.

However, despite returning to Old Trafford at the start of the summer, the Birkenhead-born defensive midfielder, who failed to make a competitive appearance for Erik ten Hag, was sold to Everton for around £15m.

MORE: Chelsea handed January boost in pursuit of £43m defensive midfielder

In light of fans’ dismay at the decision, according to a recent report from The Athletic, ten Hag played an instrumental role in allowing the 21-year-old to move on.

It has been claimed that the 52-year-old Dutch tactician did not rate Garner highly enough to consider him a candidate for regular first-team football.

Consequently, given the club’s poor record when it comes to outgoings, United’s hierarchy jumped at the chance to take the £15m on offer, rather than send the midfielder out on loan again and risk his stock declining if he did not enjoy a good spell.

More Stories James Garner