5. Kasey Keller – Leicester City, Tottenham Hotspur, Southampton, Fulham
Was a regular fixture in a talented Leicester side for three years, which included leading the Foxes to League Cup triumph in 1997 under Martin O’neill. One of a first in a new wave of American ‘keepers that shone in the top flight, Keller returned to England in 2001 to play for Spurs and spent two years as No.1 before Paul Robinson replaced him between the sticks.

