5) Andrew Johnson
Despite finishing as second highest scorer in the Premier League in 2004/05, Andrew Johnson’s goals couldn’t keep Crystal Palace from relegation that year, though his fine form later saw him join Everton.
6) James McCarthy
A superb midfielder who has only improved since joining Everton, James McCarthy’s fine form couldn’t keep Wigan up in 2013, though he famously formed part of that side that also won the FA Cup.