8 – Luke Shaw £18.48 million
Shaw was injured at the start of the season and as such has only made 16 appearances so far this season, finding it hard to work a way into the first team.
The young full back has performed reasonably, but failed to reach the heights of his Southampton days and, as of yet, has not begun to pay back his whopping £30 million fee.
5= – Ander Herrera £22 million
Another summer signing for Louis van Gaal who has impressed in his 15 appearances, scoring five goals and making three assists, but hasn’t played enough to justify being classed as a key player yet, but a more promising one for United fans.